A manager who beat the market may simply have taken more risk. This lesson shows how a planner judges managers with the Sharpe, Treynor, Jensen, information and Sortino measures, and which one fits the role a fund plays in the client's portfolio.
Sharpe and Treynor ratios
Both divide the return above the risk-free rate (the excess return) by a measure of risk:
Sharpe ratio = (Rp - Rf) / SDp Treynor ratio = (Rp - Rf) / Bp
Rp is the portfolio's return, Rf the risk-free rate, SDp its standard deviation and Bp its beta. Sharpe charges for total risk, so it fits a fund that is all or most of what the client holds. Treynor charges only for market risk, so it fits a fund that is one of many in a well-diversified portfolio, where the fund's own diversifiable risk washes out. Neither number means much alone; compare it with the benchmark's figure over the same period. Compare managers net of fees and over several years, since one year of any ratio is mostly luck.