Worked comparison
The risk-free rate is 3%, the market and benchmark returned 9%, and the market's beta is 1.
| Measure | Manager A: 10.5%, SD 15%, beta 1.1, tracking error 3% | Manager B: 9.5%, SD 11%, beta 0.75, tracking error 2% |
|---|---|---|
| Sharpe | 7.5 / 15 = 0.50 | 6.5 / 11 = 0.59 |
| Treynor | 7.5 / 1.1 = 6.82 | 6.5 / 0.75 = 8.67 |
| Jensen's alpha | 10.5 - (3 + 1.1 x 6) = 0.90% | 9.5 - (3 + 0.75 x 6) = 2.00% |
| Information ratio | 1.5 / 3 = 0.50 | 0.5 / 2 = 0.25 |
Manager B wins on three measures, but Manager A beat the benchmark more consistently per unit of tracking error. Which matters depends on the job the client is hiring the manager to do.
| Client situation | Measure that fits |
|---|---|
| The fund is the client's whole portfolio | Sharpe |
| The fund is one sleeve of a diversified portfolio | Treynor or Jensen's alpha |
| The manager is judged against a set benchmark | Information ratio |
| The client fears falling below a target return | Sortino |