Insurance is one tool among several for handling a household's risks, and buying it for the wrong exposures wastes premium. This lesson covers the four ways to handle a risk, what makes a loss insurable, the problems insurers guard against, and how to choose a deductible.
Four ways to handle a risk
A planner starts by listing what could go wrong (a death, a disability, a lawsuit, a fire, a car crash) and estimating two things for each exposure: how often a loss is likely (frequency) and how large it could be (severity). The pair points to a method.
| Low severity | High severity | |
|---|---|---|
| High frequency | Reduce and retain | Avoid |
| Low frequency | Retain | Transfer (insure) |
- Avoidance removes the exposure: not buying a trampoline, not letting a teenager drive a sports car. It suits losses that are both likely and large.
- Reduction lowers frequency or severity: smoke detectors, deadbolts, a defensive driving course. It pairs with every other method.
- Retention means the household pays the loss itself, from cash flow or an emergency fund. It suits small, predictable losses: a cracked phone screen, a minor fender-bender.
- Transfer shifts the loss to someone else, usually an insurer. It suits rare losses that would wreck the household's finances: a house fire, a liability judgment, the death of an earner.
The planning rule that follows: insure the large, rare losses first, and keep the small ones. Spending premium on small losses while leaving a large exposure uninsured is the classic mistake.
What makes a loss insurable
Insurers cover pure risks (the only outcomes are loss or no loss), not speculative risks such as a stock trade, where a gain is also possible. A pure risk is easier to insure when:
- the insurer can pool many similar, independent exposures, so the law of large numbers makes total claims predictable;
- the loss is accidental from the insured's point of view, and definite in time, place and amount;
- one event can't hit most of the pool at once (which is why flood and earthquake are sold separately, often with government involvement);
- the premium is affordable relative to the possible loss.
Two words are easy to confuse. A peril is the cause of a loss (fire, theft). A hazard is a condition that makes a loss more likely or larger: a physical hazard (frayed wiring), a moral hazard (a dishonest wish to profit from a loss, such as overinsuring a building and then setting a fire) or a morale hazard (carelessness because insurance will pay, such as leaving a car unlocked).
Adverse selection and how insurers respond
Adverse selection is the tendency of people who expect a loss to buy cover more eagerly than people who don't. If an insurer can't tell them apart, its claims exceed its pricing. Insurers respond with underwriting (health questions, inspections), waiting periods before benefits start, exclusions for conditions known at purchase where the law allows them, and group plans that enroll people for reasons unrelated to their risk.
Moral and morale hazard are handled by making the insured share the loss: deductibles, coinsurance percentages, benefit limits and the rule that insurance pays no more than the actual loss.
Choosing a deductible
A higher deductible is retention by design: the household self-insures the first part of each loss in exchange for a lower premium. The right deductible is one the household could pay from its emergency fund without strain, where the premium saved is large relative to the extra amount it would pay per claim.
Worked example: raising an auto deductible from $500 to $2,000 saves $280 a year. Each claim would now cost the household $1,500 more. The saving pays for itself unless claims come more often than $280 / $1,500 = 0.1867 a year, about one claim every 5.36 years. A careful driver with a solid emergency fund should take the higher deductible.
On the exam
- Rare, severe losses are insured; frequent, small losses are retained; frequent, severe exposures are avoided.
- Reduction combines with every other method.
- Moral hazard is dishonesty; morale hazard is carelessness.
- Adverse selection is a pricing problem from who buys; underwriting and waiting periods answer it.
- Compare deductibles by expected cost: premium plus expected retained losses.