Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Static and Flexible Budget Variances

A budget is a plan; the variance is how far actual results landed from it. This lesson covers labelling variances as favorable or unfavorable, why a static budget can mislead when volume changes, and how a flexible budget splits the gap into a volume effect and a price and spending effect.

7 cards
Study this deck

Static and Flexible Budget Variances

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

A budget is a plan; the variance is how far actual results landed from it. This lesson covers labelling variances as favorable or unfavorable, why a static budget can mislead when volume changes, and how a flexible budget splits the gap into a volume effect and a price and spending effect.

Favorable or unfavorable

A variance is the difference between an actual amount and its budget. Label it by its effect on income, not by its sign:

  • Revenue above budget is favorable; below budget, unfavorable.
  • Expense above budget is unfavorable; below budget, favorable.

A percentage variance divides the variance by the budget amount, not by the actual. Many organizations investigate variances above a set size or percentage, and look at the reasons rather than the label alone: an unfavorable materials cost can come from selling more units, which is good news.

Static and flexible budgets

A static budget is set for one planned level of activity, such as 400 events or 10,000 units. Comparing actual results with it mixes two causes: the change in volume and the change in prices and efficiency.

A flexible budget restates the budget for the actual level of activity, using the budgeted price per unit, budgeted variable cost per unit and budgeted fixed costs. It splits the static budget variance into two parts:

  • Sales-volume (activity) variance = flexible budget - static budget. It isolates the effect of selling more or fewer units at budgeted margins.
  • Flexible-budget variance = actual - flexible budget. It isolates the effect of prices, costs per unit and spending at the volume actually reached.

The two add up to the static budget variance. Fixed costs are the same in the static and flexible budgets, so any fixed-cost variance is a spending variance.

The trap a flexible budget removes: a mail-order shop budgets 120,000 of packaging for 8,000 orders. It ships 9,000 orders and spends 132,000, which looks 12,000 over the static budget. At 15 an order, the flexible budget allows 135,000, so packaging spending was actually 3,000 under (favorable).

Worked example

An event caterer budgeted 400 events at an average price of 2,500, variable costs of 1,400 an event and fixed costs of 300,000. It actually catered 440 events.

Static budgetFlexible budgetActual
Events400440440
Revenue1,000,0001,100,0001,078,000
Variable costs560,000616,000638,000
Fixed costs300,000300,000312,000
Operating income140,000184,000128,000
  • Static budget variance: 128,000 - 140,000 = 12,000 unfavorable.
  • Sales-volume variance: 184,000 - 140,000 = 44,000 favorable. Forty more events at a budgeted margin of 1,100 each.
  • Flexible-budget variance: 128,000 - 184,000 = 56,000 unfavorable, made up of revenue 22,000 unfavorable (an average price of 2,450), variable costs 22,000 unfavorable (1,450 an event) and fixed costs 12,000 unfavorable.

The static comparison says the caterer missed its profit target by 12,000. The flexible budget shows that strong volume hid weak pricing and cost control.

Reading the result

  • Variable costs above the static budget aren't a problem in themselves if volume rose; compare them with the flexible budget.
  • A small total can hide large offsetting pieces, as in the example.
  • The flexible budget uses budgeted rates. Using actual prices or costs in it would push those differences into the volume variance.
  • Variances point to who should explain them. The volume variance usually belongs to sales and demand; price and spending variances belong to whoever sets prices or controls the costs.
  • For a cost that doesn't move with volume, such as rent or insurance, the static and flexible budgets are the same, so the whole variance is spending.

On the exam

Label each variance by its effect on income. Build the flexible budget at actual volume with budgeted rates, then take flexible minus static for volume and actual minus flexible for prices and spending. Check that the two parts add up to the static variance.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Favorable versus unfavorable variance
Save
Flexible budget
Save
Sales-volume variance
Save
Flexible-budget variance
Save