Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Rent or Buy, Lease or Buy

Whether to rent or buy a home, and whether to lease or buy a car, are cost comparisons that hinge on a few assumptions. This lesson builds both comparisons, shows which costs and offsets belong in each, and names the assumptions that usually decide them.

10 cards
Study this deck

Rent or Buy, Lease or Buy

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

Whether to rent or buy a home, and whether to lease or buy a car, are cost comparisons that hinge on a few assumptions. This lesson builds both comparisons, shows which costs and offsets belong in each, and names the assumptions that usually decide them.

What owning a home really costs

A buyer's yearly economic cost is not the mortgage payment. It is:

  • Mortgage interest (principal repaid is not a cost; it becomes home equity)
  • Property taxes, homeowners insurance, and maintenance and repairs
  • The opportunity cost of the down payment: what that cash would have earned invested
  • Less any tax saving and any expected appreciation

A renter pays rent and renters insurance and keeps the down payment invested. Buying and selling also cost money (closing costs, commissions), which a short stay can't absorb.

Taxes need care. For 2026 the standard deduction is $32,200 for a joint return, and itemized state and local taxes are capped at $40,400 (reduced for modified adjusted gross income above $505,000). Mortgage interest and property tax save tax only to the extent the household's itemized deductions exceed its standard deduction. A gain on selling a main home owned and used for 2 of the last 5 years is excluded up to $250,000 ($500,000 joint).

Comparing the first year

Worked example. A couple can buy a $420,000 home with $84,000 down and a $336,000 30-year loan at 6.5%, or rent a similar home for $2,450 a month plus $240 a year of renters insurance. They take the standard deduction either way, could earn 4% after tax on the down payment, and expect 3% appreciation.

Owning, year 1Amount
Mortgage interest$21,729
Property tax, insurance, maintenance$5,200 + $1,900 + $4,200
Lost earnings on $84,000 at 4%$3,360
Less appreciation, 3% of $420,000($12,600)
Economic cost$23,789

Renting costs 2,450 x 12 + 240 = $29,640, so owning is cheaper by these assumptions. Change appreciation to zero and owning costs $36,389. The appreciation and holding-period assumptions usually decide the answer, so planners test several.

How a car lease payment works

Federal lease disclosures (Regulation M) split each payment into two parts:

  • Depreciation: (adjusted capitalized cost - residual value) / months. The adjusted capitalized cost, often just called the capitalized cost, is the agreed price plus anything financed, less any down payment or trade-in; the residual value is the car's assumed worth at lease end.
  • Rent charge: the finance cost. Dealers usually quote it as a money factor, charged monthly on (capitalized cost + residual value). By convention, money factor x 2,400 approximately equals an annual interest rate.

Example: capitalized cost $42,000, residual $25,200, 36 months, money factor 0.0025. Depreciation is 16,800 / 36 = $466.67, the rent charge is 67,200 x 0.0025 = $168.00, and the payment before tax is $634.67. The money factor is roughly a 6.0% rate.

Lease or buy

Leasing usually suits a driver who wants a new car every few years, stays within the lease's mileage allowance and keeps the car in good condition. Buying usually suits a driver who keeps cars many years, drives far or wants to modify the car, because the owner keeps the car's value after the loan is paid. A full comparison discounts each option's cash outflows, net of the car's value at the end, at the client's after-tax opportunity rate.

For 2025 through 2028, interest on a loan to buy a new U.S.-assembled car for personal use can be deductible; lease payments never qualify.

On the exam

  • Principal is not an owner's cost; interest, taxes, insurance, maintenance and lost earnings are.
  • Mortgage interest saves tax only above the standard deduction.
  • The rent charge uses capitalized cost plus residual, not minus.
  • Money factor x 2,400 approximates the rate.
  • High mileage and long ownership favor buying.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Owner's annual economic cost of a home
Save
Monthly car lease payment
Save
Money factor to annual rate
Save
When a mortgage saves tax in 2026
Save
Facts that favor buying a car over leasing
Save