ASU 2016-13 replaced "other-than-temporary impairment" with two credit loss models: expected losses for held-to-maturity securities and a capped allowance for available-for-sale securities. This lesson covers both, and how an impairment is split between net income and other comprehensive income.
Which model applies
| Category | Credit loss guidance | How losses are recorded |
|---|---|---|
| Held to maturity (amortized cost) | ASC 326-20, current expected credit losses | Allowance for lifetime expected losses |
| Available for sale (fair value through OCI) | ASC 326-30 | Allowance for the credit part of a decline, capped |
| Trading, or fair value option | None needed | Every change is already in net income |
In both models the allowance is a contra account, and changes in it are credit loss expense (or a reversal of it) in net income.
Held to maturity: expected losses from day one
For HTM securities, the allowance is the credit losses expected over the security's contractual term, so a loss is recorded at purchase even if nothing has gone wrong. The estimate uses past events, current conditions and reasonable and supportable forecasts, and is made on a pool basis for securities with similar risk characteristics and individually for those without. Amortized cost less the allowance is the net amount the holder expects to collect.
Even a very small chance of default needs an allowance, unless history adjusted for current conditions and forecasts points to an expectation of zero nonpayment; then none is required. A long record with no losses on that kind of security can support the conclusion, but the value of collateral alone can't, except where the collateral practical expedients of ASC 326-20-35-4 to 35-6 apply. A security judged uncollectible is written off against the allowance. Expected recoveries of amounts already written off are built into the allowance, up to the amounts written off; cash recoveries are recorded when received.
If an HTM security is transferred to AFS, its HTM allowance is reversed in net income, and any AFS allowance is then measured under the test below.
Available for sale: a two-question test
An AFS security is impaired when its fair value is below amortized cost. The holder then asks:
- Does it intend to sell, or is it more likely than not that it will have to sell, before amortized cost is recovered? If so, any allowance is written off and amortized cost is written down to fair value, with the whole decline in net income. The reduced amount becomes the new amortized cost.
- If not, is any of the decline a credit loss? The holder compares the present value of the cash flows it expects to collect, discounted at the effective rate at purchase, with amortized cost. Any shortfall is an allowance for credit losses, but the allowance can't exceed the amount by which fair value is below amortized cost (the fair value floor). The rest of the decline goes to OCI.
The assessment is done security by security; a general allowance for a portfolio isn't allowed. The length of time fair value has been below amortized cost can't be used, alone or with other factors, to conclude that no credit loss exists. If expected cash flows later improve, the allowance is reduced through net income, but never below zero. That reversal wasn't possible under the old model.
Worked example
A manufacturer bought a corporate bond at its 500,000 face value and holds it as AFS. At December 31 the issuer's credit has weakened and rates have risen. Fair value is 430,000, and the present value of the cash flows the manufacturer now expects, at the bond's original effective rate, is 465,000. It neither intends to sell nor expects to have to.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Total decline: 500,000 - 430,000 | 70,000 |
| Credit shortfall: 500,000 - 465,000 | 35,000 |
| Allowance (lower of the two) | 35,000 |
| Remainder to OCI | 35,000 |
Entries: Dr Credit loss expense 35,000 / Cr Allowance for credit losses 35,000; Dr OCI 35,000 / Cr AFS securities 35,000. If the present value had been 420,000, the credit shortfall of 80,000 would be capped at the 70,000 decline.
On the exam
Identify the category first. For AFS, check intent to sell before measuring any credit loss, apply the fair value floor, and send only the remainder to OCI. For HTM, the allowance is lifetime expected loss, recorded even without an observed problem, and expense is the change needed to reach the required balance after writeoffs.