When a business sells, trades in or scraps equipment it doesn't sell in its ordinary course, the gain or loss is the difference between what it receives and the asset's carrying amount on that date. This lesson covers sales, abandonments, involuntary conversions and trade-ins.
Depreciate to the date, then compare
Before removing an asset, record depreciation from the last recording date up to the disposal date. Then remove both the cost and the accumulated depreciation, record what was received, and book the difference as a gain or loss.
Example: a tour operator bought a bus on January 1, Year 1 for 180,000, with a 20,000 residual value and an eight-year straight-line life (20,000 a year). It sells the bus on September 30, Year 4 for 95,000 cash.
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Accumulated depreciation, Years 1 to 3 | 60,000 |
| Depreciation, January 1 to September 30, Year 4 (9/12 x 20,000) | 15,000 |
| Accumulated depreciation at sale | 75,000 |
| Carrying amount (180,000 - 75,000) | 105,000 |
| Loss (95,000 - 105,000) | (10,000) |
Entries: Dr Depreciation expense 15,000 / Cr Accumulated depreciation 15,000; then Dr Cash 95,000, Dr Accumulated depreciation 75,000, Dr Loss on sale 10,000 / Cr Bus 180,000.
Sales to buyers who aren't customers
Selling surplus equipment isn't revenue, because the buyer isn't a customer for the entity's ordinary output. Since ASU 2014-09 and ASU 2017-05, ASC 610-20 governs it and borrows ASC 606's control and measurement rules: derecognize the asset when the buyer obtains control, and measure the consideration as ASC 606 would, including any noncash part at fair value. The gain or loss sits in income from continuing operations, inside operating income if that subtotal is shown, unless the asset is part of a discontinued operation. The SEC staff also says gains and losses on revenue-producing equipment are a separate line, not an adjustment to depreciation.
Abandonment and idle assets
An asset to be abandoned stays classified as held and used until it actually stops being used; it is not held for sale. Once the decision is made, revise the depreciation estimates so the asset is depreciated over its shortened remaining life down to its expected salvage value. When use stops, the carrying amount left is the loss. A decision to abandon an asset well before the end of its estimated life is itself a sign that its carrying amount may not be recoverable, so the asset is tested for recoverability first. An asset that is only idle for a while is not treated as abandoned and keeps being depreciated.
Involuntary conversions
Fire, flood, theft or condemnation can turn an asset into money the entity didn't choose to receive. ASC 610-30 treats that as a disposal: recognize a gain or loss for the difference between the carrying amount and the insurance or condemnation proceeds, even if the money is reinvested in a replacement. Gain Contingencies and Commitments covers the timing.
Trade-ins and other exchanges
Since ASU 2017-05, swapping a plant asset with a party that isn't a customer, such as trading it in to a dealer, generally falls under ASC 610-20 rather than ASC 845 (845-10-15-4(k)). ASC 610-20 measures the noncash consideration at fair value, so the full gain or loss is recognized; when the fair value of what is received can't be reasonably estimated, the fair value of the asset given up is used.
For an exchange that stays within ASC 845, the asset received is measured at the fair value of the asset given up (plus any cash paid), unless the fair value of the asset received is more clearly evident, and the gain or loss is recognized in full. The exceptions use the carrying amount of the asset given up instead:
- the exchange lacks commercial substance: the entity's future cash flows are not expected to change significantly because of it;
- it swaps inventory to help either party sell to customers other than the two parties;
- the fair value of neither asset can be measured within reasonable limits.
In an ASC 845 exchange without commercial substance, the party that pays cash recognizes no gain; the party that receives cash recognizes a gain only on the portion of the deal settled in cash. Any indicated loss is recognized. If cash makes up 25% or more of the fair value of the exchange, the whole transaction is monetary and measured at fair value.
On the exam
Bring depreciation up to the disposal date first. Proceeds less carrying amount is the gain or loss. In a trade-in with commercial substance, the new asset's cost is the fair value given up plus cash paid, not the list price.