Options, short sales and borrowed money let a client hedge a holding, earn income from it or bet against a stock, but each changes the risk in ways clients often misjudge. This lesson works through covered calls, protective puts, collars, short sales and margin calls.
Calls and puts in client terms
A call gives its holder the right to buy 100 shares at the strike price until expiry; a put gives the right to sell. The buyer pays a premium; the writer (seller) keeps it and takes on the obligation. A client who already owns the shares can use options in two basic ways:
- Covered call: write calls against shares she owns. She keeps the premium as income, but if the price rises above the strike her shares are called away and she gives up the gain above it. Her downside is cushioned only by the premium.
- Protective put: buy puts on shares she owns. The put sets a floor at the strike, less the premium paid, while she keeps the upside. It works like insurance with a deductible.
Collars on a concentrated position
A collar combines the two: buy a put below the current price and write a call above it, often with premiums that roughly offset (a "zero-cost" collar). The client trades away gains above the call strike for protection below the put strike, and keeps the shares, so no sale is triggered. It suits an executive or founder with a large, low-basis position she can't or won't sell yet.
Worked example: a client owns shares at $120 with a basis of $30. She buys a put with a $110 strike for $4.20 and writes a call with a $135 strike for $4.00. Net cost = 4.20 - 4.00 = $0.20 a share. Her value at expiry is held between 110 - 0.20 = $109.80 and 135 - 0.20 = $134.80 a share.
Selling short the same stock she owns ("against the box") is a constructive sale under IRC 1259: the gain is taxed as if she had sold. That section also lets Treasury treat other positions with substantially the same effect as constructive sales, so a very tight collar needs tax advice.
Short sales
A short seller borrows shares, sells them and must buy them back later to return them. She profits if the price falls, but her loss has no ceiling if it rises, and she must pay the lender any dividends. Under Regulation T a short sale requires margin of 150% of the shares' value: the sale proceeds (100%) plus a deposit of 50%. FINRA's maintenance rule for stock sold short at $5 or more requires equity of at least the greater of $5 a share or 30% of the shares' current value.
Margin accounts and margin calls
Buying on margin means borrowing from the broker. Regulation T lets a client borrow up to 50% of the purchase price of most stocks; FINRA requires equity of at least 25% of the market value of the shares held long, and many firms demand more. If equity falls below the maintenance level, the broker issues a margin call and may sell her securities without notice. Leverage magnifies both gains and losses, and the client pays interest on the loan.
For a short position the call price is found the same way: equity = 1.5 x initial price - current price (per share), and a call comes when equity / current price falls below the maintenance percentage.
Tax notes for option writers
When a written option lapses or the writer closes it, her gain or loss is short-term, however long it was open (IRC 1234(b)). If a written call is exercised, the premium is added to her sale proceeds for the shares.
On the exam
- Covered call: income now, upside capped at the strike.
- Protective put floor = strike - premium.
- Short sales have unlimited loss and need 150% margin at the start.
- A short sale against the box is a constructive sale.
- A lapsed written option gives the writer short-term gain.