Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Conflicts, Compensation Labels and Client Disclosures

Many ethics problems start with how a planner is paid and what that pay might tempt them to do. This lesson covers how to spot a material conflict, how to disclose it well enough to earn informed consent, how to describe pay honestly, and what a client must be told at the start.

10 cards
Study this deck

Conflicts, Compensation Labels and Client Disclosures

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

Many ethics problems start with how a planner is paid and what that pay might tempt them to do. This lesson covers how to spot a material conflict, how to disclose it well enough to earn informed consent, how to describe pay honestly, and what a client must be told at the start.

Spotting a material conflict

A conflict exists when the planner's interests, or the firm's, pull against the duties owed to a client, or when duties to one client pull against duties to another. It is material when a reasonable client would think it important to their decision. Examples: a firm that owns the insurance agency its planners recommend; a payout grid that pays more for annuity sales than for advisory accounts; two clients who are each bidding for the same small business.

Gifts are a related risk. Under Standard A.6, Sound and Objective Professional Judgment, a planner may not ask for or accept anything of value, such as entertainment or a non-cash reward, that could reasonably be expected to sway their judgement.

Standard A.5, Disclose and Manage Conflicts of Interest, sets the bar. Five points decide most cases:

  • No good-faith excuse. A planner who sincerely believes the advice was in the client's interest still breaches the Standard by skipping disclosure.
  • Form. Consent need not be signed. Consent can be inferred when the disclosure was good enough, and spoken disclosure counts, though CFP Board decides how much weight to give it, so careful planners write it down.
  • Content. A footnote saying the firm "may receive third-party payments" fails. Ask whether the client could explain back what the conflict is, which arrangement creates it and why it might tilt the advice; if not, there is nothing informed to accept or refuse.
  • Harder cases. A bonus for placing clients in the firm's own private real estate fund needs far stronger proof of agreement than an ordinary fund trail. The riskier or more unusual the arrangement, the stronger the proof needed, and doubts about what a disclosure meant count against the planner.
  • Timing. Disclosure and consent come before the advice the conflict touches, never after.

Disclosure is half the job. The planner must also adopt and follow business practices that stop conflicts from distorting advice, such as level pay across similar products or a second review of every rollover recommendation.

Saying how you are paid

Standard A.12 bans false or misleading statements about how the planner or firm is paid. Its key term is sales-related compensation. Think of it as any meaningful payment that results from clients buying or selling products, or keeping them for reasons other than receiving advice, or that comes from sending a client to an outside firm: referral fees, revenue sharing, 12b-1 fees, commissions and trails are the familiar forms. So an advisory fee on assets the client holds to get advice doesn't count, and neither do research benefits within the soft-dollar safe harbor or ordinary custody fees that don't vary with client trades.

LabelWhen it may be used
Fee-onlyNeither the planner nor the firm receives sales-related compensation, and no related party receives it in connection with their services
"Fee-based" or similarOnly if it doesn't suggest fee-only and the planner clearly says they earn fees and commissions, or aren't fee-only
Fee and commissionCFP Board's own name for receiving both

A related party is anyone whose sales-related pay a reasonable planner would see as benefiting the planner or firm. Family members and businesses they control are presumed to be related parties, as are businesses the planner or firm controls, a business that controls the firm, and businesses under the same control as the firm. A related party's pay is not counted if the firm adopts and follows policies that stop its planners recommending purchases from, or referrals to, that party. A planner who controls a firm must not let it misstate its pay method; one who doesn't must correct the record with their own clients.

What the client must be told

When giving financial advice, the planner provides, before or at the start of the engagement, and documents: how the planner, the firm and any related party are paid; what the client will pay, including product costs such as sales loads and surrender charges; the material conflicts and any payment received for referring other professionals (Standard A.13); the services and products offered; any public discipline or bankruptcy and where to look it up online; the privacy policy; and anything else material. When financial planning is provided, all of these except the conflict disclosure must be given in writing, together with the engagement's scope and limits, its time period and the client's responsibilities. Carrying out, watching over and revising the plan fall to the planner unless the scope leaves them out.

The duty continues. Material changes must be passed on, and new public discipline or a bankruptcy must reach clients within 90 days, with the web address. Reports to CFP Board itself are due within 30 calendar days; the lesson on investigations covers them.

On the exam

  • Disclosure and consent must come before the advice.
  • Written consent is not required; specific, understandable disclosure is.
  • A spouse's commissions on referred clients can cost a planner the fee-only label.
  • "Fee-based" needs a clear statement that the planner also earns commissions.
  • Thirty days is the deadline for reporting to CFP Board; 90 days is the deadline for telling clients about discipline.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Material conflict of interest under CFP Board's Standards
Save
Consent to a conflict without a signature
Save
Fee-only under CFP Board's Standards
Save
Sales-related compensation, with examples
Save
Telling clients about new public discipline
Save