Closing a site, ending a product line or cutting staff creates costs, but a plan alone creates no liability. Under ASC 420, each cost is recognized when it meets the definition of a liability, at fair value. This lesson covers termination benefits, contract costs and other exit costs.
A plan is not a liability
A liability for an exit or disposal cost exists only when a past event creates a present obligation to transfer economic benefits to someone else. A board's approval of a restructuring plan doesn't do that by itself, so nothing is accrued at the approval date. Each cost has its own trigger, and each is measured at fair value when recognized. Exit costs are reported in income from continuing operations (inside operating income if that subtotal is shown), unless the activity is a discontinued operation.
One-time termination benefits
One-time termination benefits are paid to employees let go involuntarily under an arrangement set up for this termination, not under an existing severance policy. The arrangement exists on the communication date: the date the plan has been communicated to employees and meets every one of these conditions:
- the terms of the benefits are detailed enough for employees to work out what they would receive;
- the plan names the number of employees, their job functions and locations, and the expected completion date;
- the actions needed to complete the plan make significant change or withdrawal unlikely;
- management with authority to approve the plan has committed to it.
Timing then depends on future service:
- No service required, or service only within the minimum retention period: recognize the whole liability on the communication date. The minimum retention period is the legal notification period or, if there is none, 60 days.
- Service required beyond the minimum retention period: measure the liability on the communication date at its fair value as of the termination date, and recognize it ratably over the future service period.
Benefits paid under an ongoing severance plan, or a long-standing practice of paying severance, are not one-time benefits: ASC 712 accrues them when payment is probable and the amount can be reasonably estimated, or as employees earn them if the rights vest or accumulate. Extra benefits offered to employees who leave voluntarily are recognized when the employees accept and the amount can be reasonably estimated.
Contract termination and other costs
For contracts other than leases (leases fall under ASC 842):
- a fee to cancel a contract before its end is recognized when the entity terminates it under the contract's terms, for example by giving written notice;
- costs that continue under a contract with no economic benefit to the entity are recognized at the cease-use date, the date it stops using the right the contract gives it.
Other costs, such as moving equipment, relocating staff and consolidating facilities, are recognized when incurred, generally as the goods or services are received, and never earlier just because the plan makes them certain.
Later changes in the timing or amount of a recognized liability go through the same income statement line as the original charge. Until the activity is finished, the notes give the costs by reportable segment and by major type of cost (total expected, this period and to date), name the income statement lines that carry them, reconcile the liability, describe the activity and when it should finish, and explain any cost not recognized because its fair value can't be estimated.
Example
On October 1, a regional distributor communicates a plan to close a distribution center on May 31 and cut 12 office staff. There is no legal notification period.
| Cost | When recognized | Year 1 expense |
|---|---|---|
| 12 office staff leave in 30 days; 4,000 each | October 1, the communication date (within 60 days) | 48,000 |
| 40 warehouse staff get 6,000 each if they stay until May 31 | Ratably over 8 months, 30,000 a month | 90,000 |
| Fee to cancel a forklift maintenance contract; notice given November 15 | November 15 | 18,000 |
| Moving inventory to another center in May | When the movers' services are received | 0 |
| Total | 156,000 |
On the exam
Find the communication date, then ask whether employees must work beyond 60 days (or the legal notice period). Board approval alone never triggers a liability. Lease exits are ASC 842, not ASC 420.