Executives are often paid partly in promises: deferred salary, stock options, restricted shares. This lesson covers the timing rules for deferred pay, how a promise can be secured, and when each kind of equity pay is taxed, so a planner can advise on elections and sales.
Deferring pay outside a qualified plan
A nonqualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plan is a contract to pay compensation later. It need not cover rank-and-file workers, has no contribution limit, and the employer deducts the pay only when the executive is taxed on it. Section 409A sets the rules:
- Election timing: the choice to defer pay for services in a year must be made by the end of the year before. A person newly eligible may elect within 30 days, for pay earned after the election.
- Payment events: payment may be tied only to separation from service, disability, death, a fixed date or schedule, a change in control, or an unforeseeable emergency. A specified employee of a public company must wait six months after separation.
- No speeding up: payments generally cannot be accelerated, and a later change to the timing must be made at least 12 months ahead and push payment back at least five years.
A plan that breaks these rules makes all vested deferred amounts taxable at once, plus an extra 20% tax and interest.
Securing the promise
An unfunded promise is not taxed until paid, because the executive has no property set aside in their name. The cost is risk: if the employer fails, the executive is an unsecured creditor.
- A rabbi trust holds assets for the plan but leaves them reachable by the employer's general creditors in bankruptcy, so the executive is not taxed when money goes in. It protects against a change of heart, not insolvency.
- A secular trust puts assets beyond the employer's creditors, so contributions are taxed to the executive once vested.
- Assets set aside offshore, or restricted when the employer's finances weaken, are treated as transferred and taxed.
Stock options
| Feature | Nonqualified stock option | Incentive stock option |
|---|---|---|
| Grant | no tax | no tax |
| Exercise | ordinary income on the spread (market value - exercise price), as wages | no regular tax; the spread is an alternative minimum tax adjustment |
| Sale | capital gain or loss from basis = market value at exercise | long-term gain on the whole profit if held 2 years from grant and 1 year from exercise |
| Employer deduction | yes, when employee has income | none on a qualifying sale |
A sale of incentive stock option shares before both holding periods end is a disqualifying disposition: the spread at exercise becomes ordinary income, but no more than the actual gain on the sale. Only $100,000 of stock (valued at grant) may first become exercisable as incentive options in any year; the excess is treated as nonqualified.
Restricted stock and purchase plans
Restricted stock that will be forfeited if the employee leaves early is taxed when it vests, as ordinary income on its value then. A Section 83(b) election, filed within 30 days of the grant, taxes the value at grant instead; later growth is capital gain, but if the shares are forfeited no deduction is allowed for the income already reported.
An employee stock purchase plan under Section 423 lets employees buy shares at up to a 15% discount, with no more than $25,000 of stock (valued at grant) accruing per year. Holding the shares 2 years from grant and 1 year from purchase makes the profit capital gain, apart from an ordinary income slice tied to the discount.
On the exam
- Deferral elections are due by the end of the prior year.
- A rabbi trust does not trigger tax because the assets stay exposed to creditors.
- Nonqualified option: ordinary income at exercise; basis is market value then.
- A disqualifying disposition's ordinary income is capped at the gain on sale.
- An 83(b) election moves the tax to grant.