Identical goods bought at different prices raise a question: which cost goes to cost of goods sold and which stays in inventory? This lesson compares specific identification, FIFO, average cost and LIFO, under periodic and perpetual records, with one data set worked every way.
Why a cost flow assumption is needed
Once identical units bought at different prices are mixed in a warehouse, their individual costs are usually lost. GAAP lets a company assume an order in which costs flow out, choosing the method that gives the most faithful measure of each period's income:
- Specific identification uses each unit's actual cost. It suits distinct, high-value items such as vehicles or jewelry, and gives the same answer under any record system.
- First-in, first-out (FIFO) sends the oldest costs to cost of goods sold first, so ending inventory holds the newest costs.
- Average cost uses a weighted average for the whole period under a periodic system, or a moving average recomputed after every purchase under a perpetual system.
- Last-in, first-out (LIFO) sends the newest costs out first, so ending inventory holds older layers.
A company may use different methods for different parts of its inventory. Whatever it uses must be applied consistently and disclosed, and switching methods is a change in accounting principle. US tax law adds the LIFO conformity rule: a company that uses LIFO on its tax return must also use it in the income it reports to owners and creditors. Supplementary disclosure of FIFO or other amounts, such as the LIFO reserve, is allowed.
Periodic or perpetual
A periodic system counts inventory at period end and costs every sale as if it happened then, so all of the period's purchases are available to every sale. A perpetual system costs each sale when it happens, using only the units on hand at that moment. FIFO and specific identification give the same result under either system. LIFO and average cost usually don't, because the timing of sales changes which costs are available.
One data set, five answers
A distributor of commercial ceiling fans has this activity during a year:
| Date | Event | Units | Unit cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| January 1 | On hand | 1,000 | 40 |
| March 10 | Purchase | 3,000 | 44 |
| May 22 | Sale | 3,500 | |
| August 4 | Purchase | 3,000 | 50 |
| November 15 | Sale | 2,500 |
Goods available cost 322,000 for 7,000 units (40,000 + 132,000 + 150,000), and 1,000 units remain at year end.
| Method | Ending inventory | Cost of goods sold |
|---|---|---|
| FIFO, either system | 1,000 x 50 = 50,000 | 272,000 |
| Moving average, perpetual | 1,000 x 49 = 49,000 | 273,000 |
| Weighted average, periodic | 1,000 x 46 = 46,000 | 276,000 |
| LIFO, perpetual | 500 x 40 + 500 x 50 = 45,000 | 277,000 |
| LIFO, periodic | 1,000 x 40 = 40,000 | 282,000 |
Workings:
- Weighted average: 322,000 / 7,000 = 46 a unit.
- Moving average: after March, 4,000 units cost 172,000, or 43 each. The May sale leaves 500 units costing 21,500. August adds 3,000 units, giving 3,500 units costing 171,500, or 49 each.
- Perpetual LIFO: the May sale takes all 3,000 March units and 500 January units, leaving 500 at 40. The November sale takes 2,500 August units, leaving 500 at 50.
- Periodic LIFO: the 1,000 units left are costed from the oldest layer, the January units at 40.
Rising prices and the LIFO reserve
When costs rise, FIFO reports the highest ending inventory and gross profit, LIFO the lowest, and average cost falls between. Companies that report on LIFO often keep their internal records on FIFO or average cost and bridge the two with a LIFO reserve: the excess of the other measure over LIFO. Because cost of goods sold equals beginning inventory plus purchases minus ending inventory, the change in the reserve during the year is the difference in cost of goods sold. A reserve that grows means LIFO cost of goods sold is higher by that increase.
A LIFO liquidation happens when a company sells more units than it buys, so old, low-cost layers flow into cost of goods sold. Gross profit rises for a reason that won't recur.
On the exam
Check whether the question uses a periodic or a perpetual system before applying LIFO or average cost; FIFO gives the same answer either way. With rising prices, FIFO inventory is highest and LIFO lowest. Work a LIFO reserve through the cost of goods sold equation rather than memorizing a sign.