Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Paying Off and Renegotiating Debt

Debt doesn't always run to maturity on its original terms. This lesson covers when a liability is extinguished, the gain or loss on retiring debt early, when renegotiated terms count as a new loan, and how a debtor accounts for a troubled debt restructuring.

9 cards
Study this deck

Paying Off and Renegotiating Debt

In this lesson · 4 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

Debt doesn't always run to maturity on its original terms. This lesson covers when a liability is extinguished, the gain or loss on retiring debt early, when renegotiated terms count as a new loan, and how a debtor accounts for a troubled debt restructuring.

When debt is extinguished

A debtor removes a liability only when it is extinguished. That happens in one of two ways: the creditor is paid and the debt is settled, or the creditor or a court legally frees the debtor from being the primary obligor. Paying includes delivering cash, other financial assets, goods or services, and buying back its own bonds, even if it holds them as treasury bonds rather than cancelling them. Putting cash or securities into a trust that will service the debt (an in-substance defeasance) doesn't extinguish it, because the debtor is still the obligor.

On extinguishment, the gain or loss is the reacquisition price minus the net carrying amount:

  • Reacquisition price: what is paid to retire the debt, including any call premium and the costs of reacquiring it.
  • Net carrying amount: face amount plus any unamortized premium, or less any unamortized discount, and less unamortized debt issuance costs.

The gain or loss goes into income in the period of extinguishment and isn't deferred. Since ASU 2015-01 there is no extraordinary category to put it in.

Example: a hospital operator calls 2,000,000 of bonds at 102. After updating amortization to the call date, the unamortized discount is 36,000 and unamortized issuance costs are 14,000, so the net carrying amount is 1,950,000. The price is 2,040,000, so the loss is 90,000: Dr Bonds payable 2,000,000, Dr Loss on extinguishment of debt 90,000 / Cr Discount on bonds payable 36,000, Cr Unamortized debt issuance costs 14,000, Cr Cash 2,040,000.

Modification or new loan?

When a borrower and the same lender exchange or change debt terms, and the borrower isn't in a troubled restructuring, ASC 470-50 compares cash flows. Discount the cash flows under the new terms and the remaining cash flows under the old terms at the old debt's effective rate. If the two present values differ by at least 10%, the terms are substantially different: the old debt is extinguished, the new debt is recorded at fair value, and a gain or loss is recognized. If they differ by less than 10%, it is a modification: no gain or loss, and a new effective rate applies from then on. Fees the borrower pays to or receives from the lender count in the new cash flows. In an extinguishment those lender fees go into the gain or loss and third-party costs become issuance costs of the new debt; in a modification lender fees are amortized with any existing discount or premium and third-party costs are expensed.

Troubled debt restructurings: the debtor's side

A restructuring is troubled when a lender gives a borrower in financial difficulty relief it wouldn't normally offer, such as a lower rate, forgiven principal or interest, or accepting assets worth less than the debt. The lender hasn't granted a concession if the debtor's effective borrowing rate on the restructured debt is no lower than the old debt's effective rate just before the restructuring. ASU 2022-02 removed troubled debt restructuring accounting for creditors, but debtors still follow ASC 470-60:

  • Settled with assets. The debtor first adjusts the asset to fair value, recognizing a gain or loss on the asset. It then recognizes a gain on restructuring equal to the payable's carrying amount minus the asset's fair value.
  • Settled with equity. The shares are recorded at fair value, and the restructuring gain is the payable's carrying amount minus that fair value.
  • Terms modified. Compare the payable's carrying amount, including accrued interest, with the total undiscounted payments due under the new terms. If the payments are less, write the payable down to that total and recognize the difference as a gain; afterward every payment reduces the payable and no interest expense is recognized. If the payments are more, recognize no gain and use a new effective rate that equates the future payments with the carrying amount.

Example: a struggling restaurant chain owes 1,200,000 plus 60,000 of accrued interest. Its lender forgives the interest, cuts principal to 1,000,000 and charges 3% for three more years. The new payments total 1,090,000 (1,000,000 + 3 x 30,000), less than the 1,260,000 carrying amount, so the chain recognizes a 170,000 gain and carries the payable at 1,090,000, with no interest expense for the rest of its term.

On the exam

The net carrying amount includes unamortized premium, discount and issuance costs. A defeasance trust doesn't extinguish debt. For a troubled restructuring of terms, compare undiscounted totals; for a routine renegotiation with the same lender, apply the 10% present value test.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
When a liability is extinguished
Save
Gain or loss on early extinguishment of debt
Save
10% cash flow test for debt exchanges with the same lender
Save
Troubled debt restructuring
Save
Debtor's gain when troubled debt terms are modified
Save