A corporation records shares it issues at what it receives, split between par value and additional paid-in capital (APIC). Shares it buys back become treasury stock, a deduction from equity. Trading in its own shares never produces a gain or loss in net income.
Issuing shares for cash
Par (or stated) value is a legal amount per share set in the charter; it has nothing to do with market value. Proceeds equal to par go to the common or preferred stock account, and the excess to APIC. For no-par stock without a stated value, the whole amount goes to the stock account. Direct, incremental costs of an offering, such as underwriting, legal and registration fees, reduce the proceeds and so reduce APIC; they are not expenses when the offering is completed. The SEC staff takes that view for registrants, adds that general administrative costs and management salaries can't be charged to the offering, and says costs of an aborted offering can't be deferred to a later one.
When one price buys two classes of securities together, allocate it by relative fair values if both are known. If only one fair value is known, that class gets its fair value and the other gets the remainder (the incremental method).
Shares are sometimes issued before the buyer pays, for example to an officer who signs a note. A note received for shares is generally deducted from stockholders' equity, not shown as an asset, unless it is paid in cash before the statements are issued (ASC 505-10-45-2). SEC registrants must also show amounts owed by officers and directors separately.
A not-for-profit has no owners and issues no shares: its net assets are classified as with or without donor restrictions, so none of this lesson applies to it.
Issuing shares for goods or services
Shares issued to buy goods or services used in operations, from employees or anyone else, are share-based payments under ASC 718, measured at the fair value of the shares issued (ASU 2018-07 brought nonemployee payments into ASC 718). For a listed company issuing shares for land, the share price usually sets the cost of the land.
Treasury stock
Most companies use the cost method:
- Buyback: debit treasury stock at the price paid. It sits as a deduction from total equity, not an asset, and gets no dividends or votes.
- Resale above cost: credit the excess to APIC from treasury stock.
- Resale below cost: charge the shortfall to APIC from treasury stock, but only to the extent earlier treasury gains (and retirements) of that class built it up. Any remainder reduces retained earnings. APIC from the original issue can't absorb it.
Example, cost method, $1 par stock:
| Event | Entry |
|---|---|
| Issue 50,000 shares at 20; offering costs 30,000 | Dr Cash 970,000 / Cr Common stock 50,000, Cr APIC 920,000 |
| Buy back 6,000 shares at 24 | Dr Treasury stock 144,000 / Cr Cash 144,000 |
| Resell 2,000 at 30 | Dr Cash 60,000 / Cr Treasury stock 48,000, Cr APIC from treasury stock 12,000 |
| Resell 3,000 at 19 | Dr Cash 57,000, Dr APIC from treasury stock 12,000, Dr Retained earnings 3,000 / Cr Treasury stock 72,000 |
The 1,000 shares still held carry 24,000 of treasury stock. Under the par value method, an alternative, a buyback is treated like a retirement: the shares' par and their share of original APIC are removed when they are bought.
Retiring shares
When shares are retired (formally or constructively), remove their par value. If the price paid exceeds par, the excess may be:
- split between APIC and retained earnings, with the APIC part limited to APIC from earlier retirements and net treasury gains on the same issue plus the retired shares' pro rata share of that issue's other APIC; or
- charged entirely to retained earnings.
ASU 2025-12, effective for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2026 (early adoption permitted), makes explicit a third method ARB 43 allowed: charge the whole excess to APIC, as long as APIC doesn't go negative. If par exceeds the price paid, the difference is credited to APIC.
On the exam
Offering costs reduce APIC. Treasury stock reduces equity at cost; a resale shortfall uses treasury APIC first, then retained earnings, never income. Read the retirement policy before allocating the excess.