Once a client's allocation is set, the work is keeping it on target cheaply and tax-efficiently. This lesson covers when and how to rebalance, what dollar-cost averaging does and doesn't do, which account should hold which asset, and how harvesting losses fits in.
Rebalancing rules
Rebalancing restores the target mix after some holdings have grown faster than others. Without it, a 60/40 portfolio drifts toward more stock and more risk in a long rise. Two common rules:
- Calendar: rebalance on a set schedule, such as every year.
- Threshold (corridor): rebalance whenever an asset class moves outside a set range around its target, such as 5 points either way.
Narrow ranges keep risk close to target but trade more often; wide ranges cost less but allow more drift. To limit taxes and costs, a planner directs new contributions, dividends and withdrawals toward the underweight asset first, rebalances inside IRAs and 401(k)s where trades aren't taxed, and sells in taxable accounts only what remains.
Dollar-cost averaging
Dollar-cost averaging invests a fixed dollar amount at regular intervals whatever the price, so more shares are bought when prices are low and fewer when high. The average cost per share is therefore at or below the simple average of the prices on those dates.
Worked example: $900 a month at prices of $30, $20 and $25 buys 30 + 45 + 36 = 111 shares for $2,700. Average cost = 2,700 / 111 = $24.32, below the average price of $25.00.
Averaging doesn't guarantee a profit or protect against a falling market. When a client already has a lump sum and expects stocks to beat cash, investing it all at once has the higher expected return; spreading it out mainly limits the regret of buying just before a fall. Regular payroll contributions to a 401(k) are averaging by nature.
Asset location
Asset location places each holding in the account type where its returns are taxed least. Taxable accounts favor holdings whose return comes mostly as long-term gains and qualified dividends, which are taxed at lower rates, can be deferred by not selling, and can be offset by harvested losses. Tax-deferred accounts favor holdings that throw off ordinary income. Roth accounts suit the holdings expected to grow most, since qualified withdrawals are tax-free.
| Holding | Usual home | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable bond or high-yield fund | Traditional IRA or 401(k) | Interest is taxed at ordinary rates |
| REIT fund | Traditional IRA or 401(k) | Most dividends are ordinary income |
| Broad stock index fund or ETF | Taxable account | Low turnover; qualified dividends and long-term gains |
| Highest-growth stock fund | Roth IRA | Growth is never taxed if withdrawals qualify |
| Municipal bond fund | Taxable account only | Its tax exemption is wasted in an IRA |
Harvesting losses
Selling a holding below its basis realizes a capital loss that offsets capital gains and then up to $3,000 of ordinary income a year ($1,500 married filing separately; fixed by statute, not indexed), with the rest carried forward without limit. The client usually buys a similar but not substantially identical fund to stay invested. The wash sale rule disallows the loss if substantially identical shares are bought within 30 days before or after the sale, and an IRS publication says a purchase in the client's own IRA or Roth IRA counts too; the tax rules are covered in full in the tax domain.
On the exam
- Use new cash and withdrawals to rebalance before selling.
- Average cost under dollar-cost averaging is at or below the average price.
- Ordinary-income holdings go in tax-deferred accounts; munis don't belong there.
- Net capital losses offset $3,000 of ordinary income a year; the rest carries forward.