Mental accounting, defaults and self-control
Richard Thaler showed that people sort money into mental accounts and treat it differently by label, though a dollar is a dollar. One form is the house money effect: after a gain, people take bigger risks with "the market's money". Two related tendencies:
- Status quo and defaults. People tend to stay with whatever happens if they do nothing, which is why automatic enrollment raises retirement plan participation.
- Self-control. Present spending feels urgent and future goals abstract, so savings plans work better when saving happens automatically and increases are committed in advance, for example tied to future raises.
| Tendency | Where it shows up in planning | Planner response |
|---|---|---|
| Loss aversion | Refusing to sell, or to rebalance, at a loss | Reframe around the whole portfolio and the goal |
| Framing | Annuity, insurance and claiming choices | Show both frames and the numbers behind them |
| Anchoring | Retirement targets, home asking prices | Build the number from the client's own spending |
| Mental accounting | Windfalls treated as play money | Ask what the money would do in the overall plan |
| Status quo | Never revisiting an old allocation | Use defaults, automatic escalation and scheduled reviews |