Valuing the four years
College bills are paid at the start of each year and grow, so the four years form a growing annuity due. Discount them at the inflation-adjusted rate:
i* = (1 + return) / (1 + education inflation) - 1
Continuing the example with a 7% return, i* = 1.07 / 1.05 - 1 = 1.9048%.
- Value at the start of college: 50,495.73 x [1 - 1.019048^(-4)] / 0.019048 x 1.019048 = $196,390.10
- Value today: 196,390.10 / 1.07^10 = $99,834.77
The second step discounts at the nominal return, because $196,390.10 is in future dollars. Equivalently, value the four years in today's dollars at i* (using $31,000) and discount 10 years at i*; both routes give $99,834.77. Mixing them (future dollars discounted at i*) double-counts inflation.