Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Valuation Allowances and Uncertain Tax Positions

Two judgments sit on top of the deferred tax computation: whether a deferred tax asset (DTA) will be realized, and whether a tax return position will hold up. Both use a more-likely-than-not threshold, applied in different ways; this lesson works through each with numbers.

10 cards
Study this deck

Valuation Allowances and Uncertain Tax Positions

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

Two judgments sit on top of the deferred tax computation: whether a deferred tax asset (DTA) will be realized, and whether a tax return position will hold up. Both use a more-likely-than-not threshold, applied in different ways; this lesson works through each with numbers.

The valuation allowance test

A DTA needs a valuation allowance when the chance that some or all of it won't be realized is above 50% (more likely than not). The allowance cuts the DTA to the amount whose realization is more likely than not.

Realization needs enough taxable income of the right kind (for example, capital gains to absorb a capital loss), arising inside the carryback and carryforward windows the tax law allows. There are four possible sources:

  • taxable income in carryback years, if the tax law permits a carryback;
  • existing taxable temporary differences that will reverse;
  • tax-planning strategies: prudent, feasible actions the entity wouldn't ordinarily take but would take to stop a carryforward from expiring, and that would realize the DTA, such as selling appreciated assets. Their significant costs, net of tax, increase the allowance;
  • future taxable income apart from reversing differences and carryforwards.

If one source alone shows no allowance is needed, the others needn't be examined. To size an allowance, each source must be considered.

Weighing the evidence

All positive and negative evidence is weighed, and each piece counts in proportion to how objectively it can be verified. Cumulative losses in recent years are strong negative evidence and make it hard to avoid an allowance. Other negative evidence includes carryforwards that have expired unused before, losses expected in the next few years, carryforward periods too short for the deductions expected, and unresolved circumstances that could hurt profits for years.

Positive evidence that can outweigh it includes a strong earnings record in which the loss was an unusual, one-off event, assets whose value exceeds their tax basis by enough, and signed contracts or a firm sales backlog large enough to use the DTA. A forecast of profits gets less weight than objectively verifiable evidence.

A change in the opening allowance, caused by a change in judgment about future years, generally goes to income tax expense from continuing operations.

Example. A biotech company has a 400,000 operating loss carryforward, a 100,000 DTA at 25%. Existing taxable temporary differences of 160,000 will reverse within the carryforward period, supporting 40,000. Verifiable future taxable income of 120,000 supports another 30,000. The remaining 30,000 is not more likely than not to be realized:

Dr Income tax expense 30,000 / Cr Valuation allowance 30,000.

Uncertain tax positions: two steps

A tax position is a filing decision, such as a deduction, a credit or a choice not to file in a state. ASC 740-10 evaluates each position separately, with no netting against other positions:

  1. Recognition. Recognize a benefit only if the position is more likely than not to be sustained on its technical merits, assuming the taxing authority examines it with full knowledge of all relevant facts. The chance that it won't be audited is ignored.
  2. Measurement. Measure a recognized position at the largest amount of benefit that has a cumulative probability above 50% of being realized on final settlement.

The benefit claimed on the return minus the benefit recognized is an unrecognized tax benefit. It is usually a liability (or a reduction of a loss carryforward), not a deferred tax liability, and it is current to the extent cash is expected to be paid within one year or the operating cycle, if longer.

Example. A distributor claims a deduction worth 240,000 of tax and concludes it is more likely than not to be sustained. Its estimates of the settlement:

BenefitChance of realizing at least this much
0100%
100,00080%
160,00045%
240,00025%

Reading up the list, 100,000 is the highest benefit still above 50%, so it recognizes a 100,000 benefit and a 140,000 liability for unrecognized tax benefits.

Later changes, interest and disclosure

  • A benefit not recognized at first is recognized when the position becomes more likely than not, is settled, or the statute of limitations expires.
  • A benefit is derecognized as soon as the position is no longer more likely than not; a valuation allowance may not be used instead.
  • Interest starts when the tax law would start charging it, and penalties when the position is taken, if it falls short of the threshold that avoids them. By policy, interest is shown as income tax or interest expense, and penalties as income tax or another expense, applied consistently and disclosed.
  • All entities disclose interest and penalties recognized and the tax years still open to examination. Public business entities also give a table of unrecognized tax benefits from opening to closing balance and the amount that would affect the effective rate if recognized.

On the exam

Watch the thresholds: a valuation allowance and the recognition step both use "more likely than not", never ASC 450's "probable". Traps: weighting management forecasts above cumulative losses, measuring a tax position at its expected value or its single most likely outcome, and counting audit risk.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Valuation allowance threshold
Save
Sources of taxable income that support a DTA
Save
Cumulative losses in recent years
Save
Two steps for an uncertain tax position
Save
Unrecognized tax benefit
Save