Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Variable Consideration, Returns and Principal vs Agent

Step 3 of the revenue model often involves a price that isn't fixed. This lesson goes deeper on estimating variable consideration and applying the constraint, then covers sales with a right of return and whether the entity reports revenue gross, as a principal, or net, as an agent.

12 cards
Study this deck

Variable Consideration, Returns and Principal vs Agent

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

Step 3 of the revenue model often involves a price that isn't fixed. This lesson goes deeper on estimating variable consideration and applying the constraint, then covers sales with a right of return and whether the entity reports revenue gross, as a principal, or net, as an agent.

Estimating variable consideration

Consideration is variable when it can move with bonuses or penalties, rebates and discounts, refunds or credits, or a price concession. It is also variable when the customer validly expects a concession because of the entity's customary practice, or the entity intends one from the start, even if the contract states a fixed price.

The entity estimates it by whichever method better predicts what it will be entitled to:

  • Expected value: the probability-weighted sum of the possible amounts. It suits a large number of similar contracts, where data on the whole pool predicts each one.
  • Most likely amount: the single most likely outcome. It suits a single contract with two possible outcomes, such as earning or missing a bonus.

The method is applied consistently through the contract, though different uncertainties in one contract can use different methods.

The constraint

The estimate enters the price only to the extent the entity judges that a significant reversal of cumulative revenue probably won't follow once the uncertainty clears. Both the likelihood and the size of a possible reversal count. Factors pointing toward a reversal risk:

  1. The possible amounts are many and spread over a wide range.
  2. Resolution is far off, such as a fee settled only when a multi-year project ends.
  3. The amount hinges on things the entity can't influence, such as commodity prices or a regulator's ruling.
  4. The entity habitually grants a wide range of concessions, or renegotiates payment terms, in similar situations.
  5. Its experience with similar contracts is thin, or a poor guide to this one.

A partial amount can pass the constraint even when the full estimate fails. The estimate and the constraint are reassessed each reporting date. (Sales- or usage-based royalties on a license of intellectual property follow their own rule instead: revenue is recognized as the customer's sales or usage occur, or later if the related obligation isn't yet satisfied.)

Sales with a right of return

A right of return is variable consideration, not a separate performance obligation. At the sale, the entity recognizes:

  • revenue only for goods it expects to keep sold;
  • a refund liability for the consideration it expects to refund;
  • a return asset for its right to recover the goods, at their former carrying amount less expected recovery costs and any loss in value, with a matching reduction of cost of sales.

The asset and the refund liability are presented separately, not netted. Swapping one size or color for another at the same price isn't a return. Exchanging a defective item for a working one falls under the warranty guidance.

Example: a cookware maker ships 2,000 sets to retailers at 150 each (300,000), with 60 days to return them. Each set cost 96. From a long history with many similar retailers, it expects 6% (120 sets) back, each costing 4 to restock. It records:

  • Dr Receivables 300,000 / Cr Revenue 282,000 / Cr Refund liability 18,000.
  • Dr Cost of sales 180,960, Dr Return asset 11,040 / Cr Inventory 192,000. The return asset is 120 x (96 - 4).

Principal or agent

When another party is involved, the entity identifies each specified good or service and asks whether it controls that item before it passes to the customer. A principal reports the gross amount the customer pays. An agent, which only arranges for another party to provide the item, reports its fee or commission (the net amount).

Indicators of control, as amended by ASU 2016-08:

  • the entity is primarily responsible for fulfilling the promise, including its acceptability;
  • it has inventory risk before the item is transferred, or after transfer through returns;
  • it has discretion in setting the price.

The indicators support the control assessment rather than replace it, and their weight varies by contract. Momentary legal title doesn't, by itself, show control. Two indicators in the original standard, credit risk and a commission-based fee, were removed.

On the exam

Traps: expected value applied to one two-outcome bonus, a constrained bonus included because it is more likely than not, netting the return asset against the refund liability, and treating credit risk as evidence of control.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Implicit price concession
Save
Five factors that raise the risk of a revenue reversal
Save
Sale with a right of return
Save
Return asset measurement
Save
Principal vs agent
Save
Indicators that an entity is a principal
Save