A stock dividend or split gives shareholders more shares but no assets, so total equity is unchanged. A small stock dividend moves fair value out of retained earnings, a large one moves par value, and a split moves nothing. This lesson also covers property dividends.
Why no assets leave
In a stock dividend or a split, each shareholder keeps the same fraction of the company. The corporation gives up nothing, and a shareholder has no income. The accounting question is only how much of retained earnings, if any, becomes permanent paid-in capital. The answer turns on whether the new shares are few enough to leave the market price roughly where it was.
Small stock dividends
When the new shares are less than roughly 20% to 25% of those already outstanding, the market price per share barely moves, and shareholders tend to see the new shares as a distribution of earnings. The issuer therefore transfers the fair value of the new shares from retained earnings to common stock (par) and APIC (the excess). Practice uses the market price on the declaration date. At declaration the credit is to common stock dividend distributable, an equity account, not a liability; at issue it moves to common stock.
Shares held in treasury get no dividend, so count only outstanding shares. A closely held company, whose shareholders know the business, need not capitalize more than the law requires.
Large stock dividends and splits
Above roughly 20% to 25%, the new shares do cut the market price, so the distribution works like a split. Retained earnings is capitalized only to the extent the law requires, usually the par value of the new shares. If the issuer must call it a dividend for legal reasons, it can describe it as a split effected in the form of a dividend.
A stock split proper changes the par value instead: a 3-for-2 split of 6 par stock leaves each share with 4 par, and no entry is needed beyond a memo. A reverse split works the other way.
Example: a company has 80,000 shares of 6 par stock, APIC of 1,000,000 and retained earnings of 2,500,000, with a market price of 42. It weighs a 50% stock dividend against a 3-for-2 split.
| Before | 50% stock dividend | 3-for-2 split | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shares outstanding | 80,000 | 120,000 | 120,000 |
| Par value per share | 6 | 6 | 4 |
| Common stock | 480,000 | 720,000 | 480,000 |
| APIC | 1,000,000 | 1,000,000 | 1,000,000 |
| Retained earnings | 2,500,000 | 2,260,000 | 2,500,000 |
| Total equity | 3,980,000 | 3,980,000 | 3,980,000 |
Both leave equity at 3,980,000; only the dividend moves 240,000 (40,000 x 6) out of retained earnings.
Earnings per share and SEC filers
Earnings per share for every period presented is restated for stock dividends and splits, including those that occur after year end but before the statements are issued. The SEC staff also requires registrants to give retroactive effect in the balance sheet to a split or stock dividend that takes effect after the balance sheet date but before the statements are issued, with a note explaining it.
Cash and property dividends
A cash dividend has three dates. On the declaration date it becomes a liability and retained earnings falls. The record date only fixes who will be paid, so no entry is made. The payment date settles the liability. The part of a distribution that exceeds retained earnings is a liquidating dividend, a return of capital that reduces paid-in capital instead.
A dividend paid in a nonmonetary asset, such as land or investments, is measured at the asset's fair value when that value is objectively measurable and could be realized in an outright sale. The asset is first remeasured to fair value, with a gain or loss in income, and retained earnings is reduced by that fair value. A liquidation, a spinoff or other reorganization, or a plan that in substance undoes an earlier business combination uses carrying amounts instead.
On the exam
Small (under about 20% to 25%): fair value from retained earnings. Large: par value. Split: no entry, par changes. Total equity never changes; count outstanding, not issued, shares.