Cost of goods sold depends on what is counted and costed as ending inventory, so a mistake in either goes straight to profit. This lesson covers the cost of goods sold equation, which costs are inventoried, which goods a company owns at year end, and tying inventory records to a physical count.
The cost of goods sold equation
Beginning inventory + net purchases - ending inventory = cost of goods sold.
Net purchases are purchases plus freight-in, less purchase returns and allowances and purchase discounts taken. Freight-out on deliveries to customers is a selling expense, not an inventory cost. Under a periodic system, cost of goods sold is found from this equation after the year-end count. Under a perpetual system it is recorded with each sale, and the count checks the records.
Which costs are inventoried
Inventory cost is what it takes to bring goods to their present condition and location: the purchase price, inbound freight and handling, and for a manufacturer, materials, labor and production overhead. Leaving all overhead out of inventory isn't acceptable.
Variable overhead follows the actual use of the facilities. Fixed overhead uses a rate:
Fixed overhead per unit = fixed overhead / the greater of normal capacity and actual output
Normal capacity is the average output a plant expects over several periods, after planned maintenance downtime; a plant running close to it may use actual output. In a slow year the shortfall is expensed; in a busy year the lower rate stops units from carrying more than they cost.
Expensed as incurred, not inventoried:
- abnormal freight, such as shipping goods twice;
- abnormal handling;
- spoilage and wasted materials beyond normal levels;
- selling costs; and
- general and administrative costs, usually, except any part clearly tied to production.
These rules come from ARB 43 as amended by FASB Statement No. 151.
What belongs in the count
Ownership, not location, decides. A company's inventory includes:
- goods it has bought that are in transit under FOB shipping point terms, because it owns them once they ship;
- goods it has sold that are in transit under FOB destination terms, because it owns them until delivery; and
- its own goods held by dealers on consignment, which it controls until the dealer sells them to an end customer.
It leaves out goods it holds on consignment for others and goods it has sold and shipped FOB shipping point. Shipping terms come from commercial law. ASC 606's indicators of control (legal title, physical possession, the risks and rewards of ownership, a present right to payment and customer acceptance) and its consignment indicators, which govern the seller's revenue, usually point the same way.
Tying the records to the count
A garden equipment distributor with perpetual records rolls its inventory account forward and compares it with the year-end count:
| Inventory account | Amount |
|---|---|
| Beginning balance | 312,000 |
| Purchases, net of returns and discounts | 1,465,000 |
| Freight-in | 28,500 |
| Cost of goods sold per perpetual records | (1,366,900) |
| Balance per records | 438,600 |
| Physical count, adjusted for goods it owns elsewhere and goods it holds for others | 431,900 |
| Shortage | 6,700 |
Before recording a shortage, look for cutoff errors (receipts or shipments recorded in the wrong period), receipts never entered in the records and mistakes in the count. What remains is shrinkage from theft, damage or waste: Dr Cost of goods sold 6,700 / Cr Inventory 6,700. Some companies use a separate inventory loss account instead. The same check applies between the item-level subsidiary records (quantities and unit costs) and the general ledger control account, and only the record that is wrong is corrected. A 6,400 receipt posted to the item records but not the general ledger leaves the control account 6,400 too low, so a journal entry adds it. A unit cost keyed as 12.40 instead of 14.20 for 500 units understates the item records by 900, and only that item record is fixed, with no journal entry.
On the exam
Freight-in is inventory; freight-out is a selling expense. Ownership follows the shipping terms and consignment, not where the goods sit. Fixed overhead not absorbed because output was abnormally low is expensed. A shortage is recorded only after cutoff and count errors are ruled out, and only the wrong record, item records or ledger, is corrected.