A house, a car and a lawsuit can each cost a family more than it owns. This lesson covers how homeowners policies differ, how underinsuring a house cuts a claim, how the parts of an auto policy pay, and where a personal umbrella fits on top.
Homeowners policy forms
Most insurers sell standardized homeowners forms. Each policy covers the dwelling, other structures, personal property, loss of use (extra living costs while the home is repaired) and personal liability, but the forms differ in how the property is protected.
| Form | Who it suits | How the property is covered |
|---|---|---|
| HO-2 (broad) | Owner of a house | Named perils only, for dwelling and contents |
| HO-3 (special) | Owner of a house, the most common choice | Open perils (all causes not excluded) on the dwelling; named perils on contents |
| HO-5 (comprehensive) | Owner wanting the widest cover | Open perils on dwelling and contents |
| HO-4 (contents) | Renter | Named perils on contents, plus liability |
| HO-6 (unit owners) | Condominium owner | Contents, the parts of the unit the association's rules leave to the owner, plus liability |
Under a named-perils form the insured must show the loss came from a listed cause. Under an open-perils form the insurer must show an exclusion applies, so open perils is the stronger cover.
Every standard form leaves gaps a planner should ask about. Flood is excluded and is bought separately, usually through the National Flood Insurance Program. Earthquake is excluded and is added by endorsement or a separate policy. Water backing up from a sewer or sump pump needs its own endorsement. Jewelry, collectibles and similar valuables face low internal limits, so they are scheduled on a floater with their own values.
Replacement cost and the 80% rule
A replacement cost policy pays the current cost of rebuilding or buying new. An actual cash value policy pays replacement cost minus depreciation, so an old roof or sofa brings far less. Many insurers require the dwelling to be insured for at least 80% of its replacement cost for a partial loss to be paid in full, before the deductible.
If the owner carries less, the claim is cut in proportion:
Payment = (insurance carried / (80% x replacement cost)) x loss, then minus the deductible, and never more than the policy limit.
Policies differ in whether the deductible comes off before or after the fraction, and many pay at least actual cash value; a question must say which.
Worked example: a house would cost $600,000 to rebuild and is insured for $360,000. The requirement is 80% x $600,000 = $480,000. A $40,000 kitchen fire pays ($360,000 / $480,000) x $40,000 = $30,000, minus a $1,000 deductible, or $29,000. Had the owner carried $480,000 or more, the payment would have been $39,000. Rebuilding costs rise, so the limit needs checking every few years.
The parts of an auto policy
- Liability pays others for injuries and damage the insured causes. Limits are often written as three numbers in thousands, such as 100/300/50: up to $100,000 for each injured person, $300,000 for all injuries in one accident, and $50,000 for property damage. State minimums are low.
- Medical payments or personal injury protection pays the insured's own household's medical bills, depending on the state.
- Uninsured and underinsured motorist cover pays the insured's injuries when the at-fault driver has no insurance or too little.
- Collision pays for damage to the insured's car from hitting another vehicle or object.
- Comprehensive (other than collision) pays for theft, fire, vandalism, storms and falling objects.
Collision and comprehensive pay the car's market value, so on an old car of low value a planner may suggest dropping them. A car loan can exceed that value; gap cover pays the difference.
Personal umbrella liability
An umbrella policy adds liability limits, often $1 million or more, above the homeowners and auto policies, and usually covers some claims those policies don't, such as libel or slander. The insurer requires the client to keep stated underlying limits. If the client lets an underlying policy fall below the required limit, the umbrella still pays only above that required limit, and the client owns the gap. A client with substantial assets, a teenage driver, a pool or rental property is a strong candidate.
On the exam
- Open perils puts the burden on the insurer; named perils puts it on the insured.
- Flood, earthquake and sewer backup are outside a standard homeowners form.
- The coinsurance fraction uses 80% of replacement cost, not the full cost or the market value.
- Apply the per-person auto limit to each injured person before the per-accident total.
- An umbrella sits above the required underlying limits, not above what the client chose to buy.