Clients hand a planner their tax returns, health history and family secrets, and often their money. This lesson covers when a CFP® professional may share client information, how it must be protected, and the bright-line limits on loans with clients and on mixing client money with the planner's.
Who and what is protected
CFP Board's Standard A.9, Confidentiality and Privacy, covers non-public personal information about anyone the planner serves, has served or is talking to about becoming a client. A prospect who never signs up, and a client who left five years ago, are owed the same silence as a current client.
The duty has three parts beyond keeping quiet:
- No personal use. The planner may not use what a client says for the planner's own direct or indirect gain without the client's consent, even if the client loses nothing. A client who mentions that her family will sell its farmland to a developer next spring has not invited her planner to buy the lot next door.
- Security. The planner, or the firm on the planner's behalf, takes reasonable steps to guard paper files and electronic data against access that could harm or inconvenience a client: locked cabinets, encrypted laptops, care with email and shared drives.
- Written policies and notice. The planner or firm adopts policies on how client information is handled and shared, and gives each client written notice of them when the engagement starts and then at least once in every 12 months. The yearly notice can be skipped only while the policies are unchanged and the planner shares nothing beyond what is allowed without consent. A planner whose firm is subject to the SEC's Regulation S-P (or an equivalent federal or state rule) and who follows it is treated as meeting this Standard.
When sharing is allowed
Disclosure is the exception, and each exception has a purpose. Our own grouping:
| Situation | May the planner share? |
|---|---|
| A subpoena, a law, or an authorized government investigation or exam requires it | Yes, as required |
| An agent acting for the client, such as under a power of attorney, asks | Yes |
| CFP Board asks for it in an investigation | Yes |
| The planner's own lawyer, accountant or auditor needs it | Yes, as far as needed |
| The client agreed, and hasn't withdrawn consent | Yes |
| The planner reports suspected illegal activity to law enforcement | Yes, where the law permits |
| A colleague at the firm, or another professional serving the client alongside the planner, needs it to do the work | Yes, as far as needed |
| The planner sues, or defends against, a client or a government allegation | Yes, as necessary |
| A professional body reviews whether the planner meets its standards | Yes, as necessary |
| A friend at a dinner party asks how a well-known client is doing | No |
Loans between planner and client
Standard A.15 forbids a CFP® professional from borrowing money from, or lending money to, a client, directly or indirectly, with two exceptions:
- the client is a member of the planner's family, which CFP Board defines broadly (it includes, for example, cousins, in-laws, a former spouse and anyone the planner supports financially to a material extent); or
- the lender is a business whose trade is lending money, such as a bank or credit union that happens to be a client.
A friendship, a written note, fair interest or the client's eagerness does not create an exception. Section F of the Code, Prohibition on Circumvention, also bars doing indirectly what can't be done directly, so a loan routed through the planner's spouse or wholly owned company fails too.
Keeping client money separate
The same Standard bars commingling: a client's financial assets may not be mixed with the planner's or the firm's. Depositing a client's check for an insurance premium into the firm's operating account, or holding a client's securities in the planner's personal brokerage account "for convenience", breaches it even if every dollar is later passed on. Client funds belong in accounts titled to the client or held by a qualified custodian.
On the exam
- Former and prospective clients are protected, not just current ones.
- Using client information for personal gain is barred even when the client suffers no harm.
- The annual privacy notice may be skipped only if policies are unchanged and nothing is shared beyond the permitted exceptions.
- Loans to or from clients: only family members or lending businesses. Friendship and fair terms don't help.
- A loan or account arrangement routed through someone else is still covered.