A client's statement, a fund fact sheet and a manager's report can show three different returns for the same year. This lesson computes holding period, average, time-weighted, dollar-weighted, real and after-tax returns, and says which one answers which client question.
Holding period return and annualizing
The holding period return (HPR) is the whole gain over the time held, income included:
HPR = (ending value - beginning value + income) / beginning value
Worked example: a client paid $25,000 for shares, received $600 of dividends, and sold them 18 months later for $26,900. HPR = (26,900 - 25,000 + 600) / 25,000 = 10.00%. To compare it with yearly figures, annualize by compounding: (1.10)^(1 / 1.5) - 1 = 6.56% a year. Dividing 10% by 1.5 would overstate it. Industry standards don't annualize returns for periods shorter than a year, because that assumes a short run repeats.
Arithmetic and geometric averages
The arithmetic mean adds the yearly returns and divides by the number of years. If returns are independent from year to year, it is the best single guess for one future year. The geometric mean is the constant rate that turns the starting value into the ending value:
Geometric mean = [(1 + r1) x (1 + r2) x ... x (1 + rn)]^(1/n) - 1
The geometric mean is never above the arithmetic mean, and the gap widens with volatility (volatility drag). A fund that gains 50% and then loses 50% has an arithmetic average of 0% but leaves the client with 75% of her money. Wealth follows the geometric figure.
Time-weighted returns
A time-weighted return (TWR) removes the effect of the client's deposits and withdrawals. Split the period at each external cash flow, compute each subperiod's return, and link them:
TWR = (1 + R1) x (1 + R2) x ... x (1 + Rk) - 1
Because the manager doesn't control when clients add or take money, TWR is the fair way to judge the manager or compare a fund with its benchmark. Funds publish time-weighted figures.
Dollar-weighted returns
A dollar-weighted (money-weighted) return is the internal rate of return (IRR) of the client's own cash flows: the rate at which the present value of contributions equals the present value of withdrawals plus the ending value. It gives more weight to periods when more of the client's money was invested, so it measures the client's actual experience, including her timing. When a client adds money before a fall, her dollar-weighted return trails the fund's time-weighted return.
On a financial calculator, enter money the client puts in as negative cash flows and money she takes out as positive ones, add the ending value as the last positive flow, and solve for IRR. With yearly flows the result is a yearly rate; with monthly flows, annualize the monthly IRR by compounding.
| Question the client asks | Measure to use |
|---|---|
| How did my manager do against the index? | Time-weighted |
| How did my money actually grow, given when I added it? | Dollar-weighted |
| What steady yearly rate matches my result? | Geometric mean |
| What should I expect in a single year? | Arithmetic mean |
Real and after-tax returns
Real return removes inflation: (1 + nominal) / (1 + inflation) - 1. The shortcut nominal minus inflation is close only when rates are low. Taxes fall on the nominal return, so a planner taxes first and deflates second: real after-tax = [1 + r x (1 - t)] / (1 + inflation) - 1. A taxable bond fund in a high bracket can earn little or nothing after both.
On the exam
- Annualize multi-period returns by taking roots, not by dividing.
- A +X% year followed by a -X% year loses money.
- Link subperiod returns by multiplying; don't add them or average them.
- TWR judges the manager; dollar-weighted reflects the client's own deposits and withdrawals.
- Over several years, divide growth by cumulative inflation, then annualize; tax the nominal return before deflating.