Since ASU 2016-01, an equity investment that isn't consolidated or under the equity method is measured at fair value through net income, unless it has no readily determinable fair value and the holder elects the measurement alternative. This lesson covers both, and impairment under the alternative.
Which investments this covers
ASC 321 applies to shares and other ownership interests, including interests in partnerships and limited liability companies, held by an entity that does not consolidate the investee or apply the equity method to it. It does not cover:
- investments in subsidiaries (consolidated) or under the equity method;
- derivatives accounted for under ASC 815;
- Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank stock, and certain exchange memberships;
- entities, such as investment companies and broker-dealers, whose industry guidance already carries substantially all investments at fair value through earnings.
Preferred stock that the issuer must redeem, or that the holder can require it to redeem, is a debt security under ASC 320, not an equity security.
Equity securities have no available-for-sale or held-to-maturity category. Before ASU 2016-01, unrealized gains on available-for-sale stock went to other comprehensive income (OCI); that treatment is gone.
Fair value through net income
At each reporting date the investment is remeasured to fair value, and the unrealized holding gain or loss goes to net income. Dividends are also income. Because the carrying amount already equals the last fair value, a sale produces a gain or loss only for the change since the last remeasurement.
Example: a hardware wholesaler buys two listed stocks in Year 1.
| Item | Stock P | Stock Q | Net income |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost, Year 1 | 42,000 | 45,000 | |
| Fair value, December 31, Year 1 | 47,000 | 42,000 | 2,000 gain |
| Q sold in March, Year 2, proceeds | 46,500 | 4,500 gain | |
| Dividend on P, Year 2 | 1,200 | ||
| Fair value of P, December 31, Year 2 | 44,000 | 3,000 loss |
Year 2 net income includes 4,500 + 1,200 - 3,000 = 2,700. The sale entry is Dr Cash 46,500 / Cr Equity securities 42,000 / Cr Gain on equity securities 4,500. The 1,500 total gain on Q since purchase (46,500 - 45,000) was split across the two years.
Shares without a readily determinable fair value
A fair value is readily determinable when sales prices or quotes are currently available on an SEC-registered exchange or a qualifying over-the-counter market (restricted stock qualifies if the restriction lapses within a year), or on a foreign market of comparable breadth and scope, or when the security is a fund share with a published net asset value used in current trades. Shares of a private company usually have none.
For such a security, an entity may elect, investment by investment, the measurement alternative: cost, less impairment, plus or minus changes shown by observable prices in orderly transactions for the identical or a similar security of the same issuer. ASU 2018-03 clarified that each adjustment reflects fair value at the date of that transaction. The alternative is not available for an investment that qualifies for the net asset value practical expedient. An entity using it may later switch to fair value, irrevocably, for all identical or similar investments in that issuer.
Impairment under the measurement alternative
Securities carried at fair value need no impairment test. Under the measurement alternative, the entity makes a qualitative assessment every reporting period. Signs of impairment include:
- a sale offer, bid or auction for the same or a similar security below its carrying amount;
- doubts about the investee's ability to continue as a going concern, such as negative operating cash flows or covenant breaches;
- a significant decline in the investee's earnings, credit rating, asset quality or prospects;
- a significant adverse change in its regulatory, economic or technological environment, or in the market for its region or industry.
If the qualitative assessment points to impairment, the entity estimates fair value and, if it is below the carrying amount, writes the security down to it, with the whole difference in net income.
On the exam
Unrealized changes on equity securities go to net income, never to OCI. A sale gain runs from the last carrying amount, not from original cost. Under the measurement alternative, an observable orderly transaction moves the carrying amount up or down, and impairment writes it down to fair value, not just back to cost.