Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Choosing a Business Entity for Tax

Whether a business pays tax itself or passes its income to its owners shapes the owner's tax bill, payroll tax and use of losses. This lesson compares sole proprietorships, partnerships, LLCs and S and C corporations the way a planner weighs them for a client who owns a business.

10 cards
Study this deck

Choosing a Business Entity for Tax

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

Whether a business pays tax itself or passes its income to its owners shapes the owner's tax bill, payroll tax and use of losses. This lesson compares sole proprietorships, partnerships, LLCs and S and C corporations the way a planner weighs them for a client who owns a business.

Who pays the tax, the business or its owners

A C corporation is a separate taxpayer. It pays a flat 21% on its taxable income, and owners pay tax again on dividends, usually at 15% or 20% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax for high earners. That second layer applies only when profits leave the company, so a C corporation that keeps its earnings defers it.

Every other common form is a pass-through. A sole proprietor reports profit on Schedule C of their own return. A partnership and an S corporation file information returns and send each owner a Schedule K-1; owners pay tax on their shares whether or not cash is distributed. Pass-through owners may also qualify for the 20% qualified business income deduction, taught in the next lesson.

A limited liability company (LLC) is a state-law label, not a tax category. Unless it elects otherwise, an LLC with one owner is disregarded (taxed like a sole proprietorship) and one with two or more owners is a partnership. It can elect to be taxed as a corporation, and then as an S corporation.

Worked example: Ottilie's company earns $100,000 more than it needs this year. As a C corporation that keeps the money, it pays 21% x $100,000 = $21,000 now. As a pass-through, the $100,000 is taxed on her return at her 35% marginal rate, $35,000, but no second tax arises later.

Keeping an S election valid

An S corporation must be a domestic corporation with:

  • no more than 100 shareholders, with a family (a common ancestor, their descendants and the spouses or former spouses of any of them) counted as one;
  • only eligible shareholders: individuals who are US citizens or residents, estates, and certain trusts such as grantor trusts; no partnerships, no C corporations and no nonresident aliens;
  • one class of stock. Differences only in voting rights are allowed; different rights to distributions or liquidation proceeds are not.

Breaking any rule ends the election, and the company becomes a C corporation, unless the IRS grants relief for an inadvertent termination (IRC 1362(f)).

Paying the owners

FormHow an owner-worker is paidPayroll or self-employment tax
Sole proprietorship or single-member LLCTakes the profitSelf-employment tax on net earnings
PartnershipGuaranteed payments plus a share of profitGeneral partner: both; limited partner: only guaranteed payments for services
S corporationWages plus distributionsPayroll tax on wages only
C corporationWages and dividendsPayroll tax on wages; dividends taxed twice

An owner who works in an S corporation should draw a salary that matches the value of the work; only what is left can come out as distributions free of payroll tax. If the salary is too low or zero, the IRS can treat part of the distributions as wages and assess payroll tax. In a C corporation the pressure runs the other way: pay well above market value can be recast as a nondeductible dividend.

Courts have used different tests for whether a state-law limited partner who helps run the business keeps the exclusion for their share of profit, and the recent ones deny it to partners who manage or control the business (Tax Court, Soroban, 2023; Fifth Circuit, Sirius Solutions, 2026; Second Circuit, Soroban, 2026).

Deducting losses from a pass-through

An owner can deduct a pass-through loss only up to their basis, and the excess carries forward. A partner's basis includes their share of the partnership's debts. An S corporation shareholder's basis covers only their stock and loans they made directly to the company; guaranteeing a bank loan to the company adds nothing until the shareholder actually pays on it.

Worked example: Darius has a $30,000 basis in his partnership interest and his share of this year's loss is $45,000. He deducts $30,000 now and carries $15,000 forward until his basis grows. The at-risk and passive activity rules, taught with rentals, may limit the deduction further.

On the exam

  • An LLC's tax treatment depends on its owner count and any election, not its name.
  • One nonresident alien shareholder ends an S election; voting differences alone do not.
  • S corporation distributions escape payroll tax only if the owner's wages are reasonable.
  • A shareholder's guarantee of a company loan does not create basis.
  • For a partner treated as a limited partner, the share of profit is not self-employment income, but guaranteed payments for services are.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Default tax classification of an LLC
Save
S corporation eligibility rules
Save
Reasonable compensation (S corporation)
Save
Loss limit for an S corporation shareholder
Save
Self-employment income of a limited partner
Save