Whenever a CFP® professional gives a client financial advice, that advice must serve the client first. This lesson shows when the fiduciary duty applies, what loyalty, care and following instructions ask of a planner day to day, and how to tell a breach from a judgement call.
When the duty applies
CFP Board's Standard A.1, Fiduciary Duty, attaches to an act, not to a job title or a way of being paid. Two things must both be present. The first is a client: someone the planner has agreed to serve, under an engagement that may be written, spoken or simply understood. The second is financial advice: a communication a reasonable observer would read as a recommendation to act, or to hold back, on investments, insurance or other financial assets, on a plan, on hiring another professional, or through discretionary authority over the client's assets.
A workshop handout on how bond prices react to interest rates is education: it tells no one what to do. Telling an attendee who has booked a paid review to sell her bond fund is advice, and the planner can't undo that by saying she meant it only as background, because the message is judged by how a reasonable professional would read it.
Pay and product don't change the answer. A planner who sells insurance on commission, recommends a brokerage trade or bills by the hour is a fiduciary for that advice. One-off advice creates the duty for that recommendation; an ongoing duty exists only while the planner keeps advising or monitoring.
Loyalty
Loyalty puts the client's interests ahead of the planner's and the firm's. In practice the planner either avoids a conflict or explains it fully, obtains the client's informed consent and manages it (the lesson on conflicts covers how). Consent does not end the duty. A planner who has disclosed the commission on one annuity must still recommend the other contract if it serves the client better. A useful test: would I make this recommendation if I were paid the same whichever option the client chose?
Care
Care is judged against what a skilled, prudent practitioner would do for this particular client, given what the client wants to achieve, how much risk they will accept and the rest of their personal and financial picture. A recommendation that suits most people of the same age can still breach care if it ignores a fact the planner knew, or should have asked about, such as a home purchase planned in two years.
Two neighboring Standards support care. Under Standard A.3, Competence, a planner out of her depth must refer the client, bring in a qualified colleague, narrow or end the engagement, or build the skill, and must say which requested services she won't provide. Under Standard A.4, Diligence, work and replies to reasonable questions must be timely and thorough.
Following instructions
The planner must keep to the terms of the engagement, including its goals, policies and restrictions, and to the client's reasonable and lawful directions. If a client bars weapons makers from her portfolio, or caps any one holding at a set percentage, those limits bind until she changes them. A direction that is unlawful, such as backdating a gift letter, or unreasonable need not be followed; the planner explains why and, if needed, narrows or ends the engagement.
Following instructions isn't the same as agreeing. When a client insists on a lawful choice the planner thinks unwise, the planner explains the risks, records the conversation and may then carry out the instruction.
The three duties side by side
| Duty | Question to ask | Typical breach |
|---|---|---|
| Loyalty | Whose interest drove this choice? | Choosing the better-paying product when another fits the client better |
| Care | Would a prudent expert advise this client this way? | Locking up money the client needs soon |
| Following instructions | Does this respect the engagement terms and the client's lawful directions? | Ignoring a written restriction because the planner disagrees with it |
On the exam
- Find the advice first: with no client or no tailored recommendation, Standard A.1 does not apply.
- Commission pay, insurance products and one-off advice don't switch the duty off.
- Disclosure and consent manage a conflict; they never license a worse recommendation.
- Care is measured against this client's facts, not a typical client's.
- Instructions bind only when they are reasonable and lawful.