Defined benefit plans promise an income; defined contribution plans promise only what an account earns, and two hybrids sit between them. This lesson covers how each sets the benefit, who bears the investment risk, which ones the federal insurer covers, and whom each suits.
How a traditional pension sets the benefit
A defined benefit plan states the retirement benefit, usually as a life annuity from normal retirement age, and the employer must fund it. Common formulas:
- Flat amount: a set dollar sum a month, such as $50 for each year of service.
- Flat percentage: a set percentage of pay, such as 40% of final average pay.
- Unit credit: a percentage of pay for each year of service, such as 1.5% x years x final average pay.
Final average pay (often the highest three or five years) protects the benefit against inflation before retirement better than career average pay. Example: 1.5% x 25 years x $120,000 = $45,000 a year.
For 2026 the yearly benefit is limited to the lesser of $290,000 or 100% of the participant's average pay over the highest three consecutive years, and no more than $360,000 of a year's pay may be counted. The $290,000 applies to a life annuity starting from age 62 to 65; it is reduced for an earlier start and raised for a later one. The dollar limit is scaled down for a participant with fewer than 10 years in the plan.
Who carries the risk and who insures it
An actuary sets the yearly contribution needed to fund the promised benefits, and minimum funding rules make the employer pay it. If investments fall short, the employer must contribute more, so the employer bears the investment risk. Because a benefit for a worker near retirement must be funded over few years, the required, deductible contribution can be very large for an older owner.
The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) insures benefits in most private defined benefit plans, up to legal limits, if a plan ends underfunded. It does not cover defined contribution plans, and it does not cover a plan of a professional service employer, such as a medical or law practice, that has never had more than 25 active participants.
Cash balance plans
A cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan that looks like an account. Each year the participant's hypothetical account gets a pay credit (a percentage of pay) and an interest credit (a stated rate or an index, which may not exceed a market rate). The plan's actual investment results do not change the credits, so the employer still bears the investment risk. Participants vest fully after three years of service, can usually take the account as a lump sum when they leave, and are generally covered by the PBGC.
Target benefit plans
A target benefit plan is a defined contribution plan. An actuarial formula sets each year's contribution so that, at an assumed rate of return, it would fund a target pension; older entrants get larger contributions. Once made, the contribution goes into the participant's real account, and the participant bears the investment risk: the target is not promised. The 2026 limit on yearly additions to the account, $72,000 or 100% of pay if less, applies, and the PBGC does not cover it.
Choosing among them
| Feature | Traditional defined benefit | Cash balance | Target benefit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal type | defined benefit | defined benefit | defined contribution |
| Investment risk | employer | employer | employee |
| Yearly limit, 2026 | $290,000 benefit | $290,000 benefit | $72,000 contribution |
| PBGC insurance | yes, with exceptions | yes, with exceptions | no |
| Portability | annuity, sometimes lump sum | lump sum usual | account balance |
A profitable firm with an older owner who wants to save far more than $72,000 a year usually looks at a defined benefit or cash balance plan. A firm that wants predictable costs looks at defined contribution plans.
On the exam
- A cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan, with employer risk and PBGC cover.
- A target benefit plan is a defined contribution plan; the target is not guaranteed.
- Count only $360,000 of pay for 2026, and cap the benefit at $290,000 or 100% of high-three pay.
- The interest credit, not the trust's return, builds a cash balance account.