The split among stocks, bonds and cash drives most of a portfolio's risk and return, so a planner sets it before choosing funds. This lesson weighs a client's willingness, ability and need to take risk, uses the efficient frontier, separates strategic from tactical moves and records the result.
Willingness, ability and need
Three questions set how much risk a client should take:
- Willingness (risk tolerance): how she feels about losses, judged from questionnaires, conversation and what she actually did in past downturns.
- Ability (risk capacity): how much loss her finances can absorb without derailing her goals, given her time horizon, income security, reserves and the size of her portfolio relative to her needs.
- Need (required return): the return her goals require. A client who can reach her goals with low returns needn't take much risk, however much she could bear.
When willingness and ability disagree, the planner generally follows the lower of the two and explains why. Raising risk beyond what a client will stick with tends to end in selling at a low; raising it beyond her capacity can make a market fall permanent damage.
Worked example: a client with $250,000 needs $400,000 in 12 years and will add nothing. Her required return is (400,000 / 250,000)^(1/12) - 1 = 3.99% a year. A 70/30 mix with expected returns of 7.5% for stocks and 4.0% for bonds offers 0.7 x 7.5 + 0.3 x 4.0 = 6.45%. She could reach the goal with less stock if her tolerance is low.
Diversification and the efficient frontier
Combining assets that don't move in lockstep lowers risk without lowering expected return. Plotting every mix by expected return and standard deviation gives a set of best choices, the efficient frontier: for each level of risk, the highest expected return available. A portfolio below the frontier is dominated, because another mix offers more return for the same risk or the same return for less. The planner's job is to pick the point on the frontier that fits the client, not to find a single best portfolio for everyone.
Strategic and tactical allocation
The strategic allocation is the long-term policy mix, with a target and a permitted range for each asset class, set from the client's goals and risk profile. It changes when her circumstances or goals change, not when markets move. A tactical allocation is a deliberate, temporary tilt away from the targets, usually inside the ranges, to exploit a view on valuations or the economy; it returns to target when the view plays out. Tactical moves add costs, taxes and the risk of being wrong, so many planners limit or avoid them.
| Feature | Strategic | Tactical |
|---|---|---|
| Horizon | Years | Months |
| Set by | Goals, horizon and risk profile | A market view |
| Changes when | The client's life or goals change | The view changes or plays out |
Writing it down
An investment policy statement (IPS) records the plan so that client and planner can hold to it in hard markets. Ours would cover the client's goals and time horizon, her return need and risk profile, the target weights and ranges, the rebalancing rule, holdings she won't own, when she'll need cash, how her accounts are taxed and any legal limits on the accounts, the benchmarks used to judge results, and how often the IPS is reviewed. It contains no forecasts or promised returns.
On the exam
- Follow the lower of willingness and ability; check need before adding risk.
- A dominated portfolio has a rival with more return at equal risk, or equal return at less risk.
- Strategic is the policy; tactical is a temporary tilt within it.
- Required return comes from compounding, not from dividing the total gain by the years.