Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Annuity Contracts, Riders and Their Taxation

An annuity is the one product that can promise income for as long as a client lives, and it also defers tax on growth. This lesson covers the main annuity types, the riders sold with them, and how withdrawals, annuity payments, exchanges and inherited contracts are taxed.

10 cards
Study this deck

Annuity Contracts, Riders and Their Taxation

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

An annuity is the one product that can promise income for as long as a client lives, and it also defers tax on growth. This lesson covers the main annuity types, the riders sold with them, and how withdrawals, annuity payments, exchanges and inherited contracts are taxed.

Fixed, indexed and variable annuities

  • A fixed annuity credits a rate the insurer declares, with a guaranteed minimum. The insurer bears the investment risk.
  • An indexed annuity credits interest by a formula tied to a market index. A participation rate sets the share of the index gain credited, a cap sets the most that can be credited, and a floor, often zero, protects against index losses. When both apply, the credit is the lower of the gain times the participation rate and the cap. Many indexed annuities are regulated by the states as insurance products; those that are securities come with a prospectus.
  • A variable annuity invests in subaccounts the owner chooses, so the owner bears the market risk. It is a security, sold with a prospectus, and carries mortality and expense charges, fund expenses and rider fees.

Annuities are deferred (built up first, then paid out) or immediate (paid out starting within about a year). Deferred contracts often carry surrender charges for several years.

Riders and payout options

Variable annuities usually include a basic death benefit that pays heirs no less than what was paid in, net of withdrawals, even after a market fall. Optional riders, each with a yearly charge, include:

  • an enhanced death benefit that locks in market highs on set dates;
  • a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit, which lets the owner withdraw a set percentage of a benefit base for life, even if the account runs out;
  • a guaranteed minimum income benefit, which guarantees a floor for income if the owner annuitizes;
  • a guaranteed minimum accumulation benefit, which guarantees the account value after a waiting period.

At annuitization the owner chooses how payments are made: for one life only (the highest payment, nothing left at death), life with a period certain, a cash or installment refund of the unrecovered premium, or joint and survivor for a couple. More guarantees mean a smaller payment.

Taxing withdrawals and annuity payments

Growth inside a nonqualified annuity isn't taxed until it comes out. The owner's basis, the investment in the contract, is the after-tax money paid in.

Withdrawals before annuitization come out of gain first: each is taxable until all gain has been withdrawn, then basis comes out tax-free. A taxable withdrawal before age 59½ also carries a 10% additional tax unless an exception applies, such as death, disability or a series of substantially equal payments for life.

Annuity payments are split by the exclusion ratio:

Exclusion ratio = investment in the contract / expected return

For a life annuity, the expected return is the yearly payment times the IRS life expectancy multiple for the annuitant's age. That fraction of each payment is a tax-free return of basis until the whole basis has been recovered; after that, every payment is fully taxable. If the annuitant dies before recovering it all, the unrecovered basis is deductible on the final return.

Worked example: a 65-year-old with $151,200 invested buys a life annuity of $900 a month. The expected return is $900 x 12 x 20.0 = $216,000, so the ratio is $151,200 / $216,000 = 70%. Each month $630 is tax-free and $270 taxable, until the basis is recovered after 20 years.

Exchanges and the owner's death

Under Section 1035 an annuity can be exchanged tax-free for another annuity or a qualified long-term care contract, carrying over the old basis, which lets a client leave a high-cost contract. A new surrender charge period may start, so the exchange must benefit the client.

An annuity gets no step-up in basis at death. A beneficiary who receives the contract owes ordinary income tax on the gain as it is paid out, as income in respect of a decedent. If the owner dies before payments start, the contract must generally be paid out within five years, or over the beneficiary's life starting within a year; a surviving spouse may instead continue the contract as owner.

On the exam

  • Indexed credit = the lower of (index gain x participation rate) or the cap.
  • Withdrawals come from gain first; annuity payments use the exclusion ratio.
  • The 10% additional tax applies to taxable withdrawals before 59½.
  • Inherited annuity gain is ordinary income, with no step-up.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Exclusion ratio for annuity payments
Save
Withdrawal from a deferred nonqualified annuity before annuitization
Save
Indexed annuity credit with a participation rate and a cap
Save
Guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit
Save
Inherited nonqualified annuity
Save