A company can turn receivables into cash before customers pay by selling them or by borrowing against them. This lesson covers ASC 860's three conditions for sale accounting, factoring with and without recourse, and loans backed by receivables.
Sale or borrowing: the three conditions
A transfer of receivables (whole receivables, a group of them, or a participating interest in one) is a sale only if the transferor gives up control. ASC 860 tests control with three conditions, and all three must be met:
- The transferee is free to use the assets. It may pledge or sell what it received, and no condition both restricts that right and gives the transferor more than a trivial benefit.
- The transferor keeps no effective control. For example, it hasn't given the transferee a put priced so favorably that exercise is probable, it can't unilaterally reclaim specific receivables (other than through a cleanup call), and no agreement both entitles and obligates it to buy the receivables back before they mature.
- The assets are isolated. They are beyond the reach of the transferor and its creditors, even in bankruptcy.
If any condition fails, both parties account for a secured borrowing: the receivables stay on the transferor's balance sheet and the cash received is a liability. Recourse, an obligation to cover customer defaults, doesn't by itself prevent a sale. In a sale it becomes a liability measured as part of the proceeds.
Factoring
Factoring is selling receivables to a finance company, the factor, which usually tells the customers to pay it directly. When the transfer is a sale, the transferor:
- removes the receivables and the allowance that relates to them;
- records what it received at fair value: cash, any amount the factor holds back against returns and disputes (a receivable from the factor), and any recourse obligation as a liability; and
- recognizes in earnings the difference between those net proceeds and the receivables' carrying amount. The factor's fee usually makes it a loss.
Example: a commercial roofing contractor factors 250,000 of receivables, which carry a 6,000 allowance, with recourse for customer defaults. The factor charges a 3% fee (7,500) and holds back 5% (12,500) until the accounts are collected, so it pays 230,000 now. The recourse obligation has a fair value of 4,000, and all three conditions are met.
| Entry at transfer | Dr | Cr |
|---|---|---|
| Cash | 230,000 | |
| Due from factor | 12,500 | |
| Allowance for credit losses | 6,000 | |
| Loss on sale of receivables | 5,500 | |
| Accounts receivable | 250,000 | |
| Recourse liability | 4,000 |
The loss is the receivables' carrying amount of 244,000 (250,000 - 6,000) less the net proceeds of 238,500 (230,000 + 12,500 - 4,000). Without recourse, the factor bears the credit losses, its fee is usually higher, and there is no recourse liability.
Loans backed by receivables
When receivables back a loan instead of being sold, none of them leaves the balance sheet and no gain or loss arises.
- Pledging. The receivables as a whole serve as collateral for a loan. The loan is recorded as usual, and the carrying amount and classification of the pledged receivables are disclosed. If the lender may sell or repledge them, the borrower reports them separately from its other receivables.
- Assignment. The borrower signs a note and assigns specific accounts to the lender. It usually keeps collecting from those customers and passes the cash on, which reduces the note. Many companies show the assigned accounts on their own line, and the arrangement is disclosed. Example: a dental lab assigns 80,000 of accounts to a bank as security for a 60,000 note: Dr Cash 60,000 / Cr Notes payable 60,000. Fees and interest paid to the bank are part of the cost of borrowing.
- Failed sale. A transfer that misses any of the three conditions is recorded as Dr Cash / Cr Secured borrowing (a liability). The receivables stay, collections pay down the liability, and anything paid to the transferee beyond the cash it advanced is interest.
On the exam
Check the three conditions before computing anything. In a sale, the loss is carrying amount minus net proceeds: the holdback is an asset, the recourse obligation reduces proceeds, and the related allowance leaves with the receivables. In a borrowing, nothing is derecognized and no gain or loss is recorded.