Choosing a life policy means matching how long the need lasts and how much the client can pay to a design, then avoiding the tax traps that can turn a tax-free benefit into income. This lesson compares the main designs and the income tax rules that follow them.
Term or permanent cover
Term insurance pays only if the insured dies within the term. It has no cash value, so it buys the most death benefit per premium dollar. Level term keeps the premium flat for 10, 20 or 30 years; annual renewable term starts cheap and rises each year. Many policies are convertible into permanent cover without new medical evidence, which protects an insured whose health later worsens.
Permanent insurance is meant to last for life and builds a cash value the owner can borrow or withdraw.
| Design | Premium | Cash value | Who bears investment risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whole life | Fixed | Guaranteed, plus dividends if participating | Insurer |
| Universal life | Flexible within limits | Credited with a declared rate; charges deducted | Owner, above a guaranteed minimum rate |
| Variable universal life | Flexible | Invested in subaccounts the owner picks | Owner |
| Indexed universal life | Flexible | Credited by an index formula with a floor and cap | Shared |
Universal life lets the owner choose a level death benefit or one that rises with the cash value. If credited rates fall or charges rise, an underfunded universal policy can lapse, so it needs regular in-force illustrations. Variable policies are securities, sold with a prospectus by registered representatives.
A simple guide: a temporary need, such as raising children or paying off a mortgage, calls for term; a permanent need, such as estate liquidity or a lifelong dependent, calls for permanent cover.
The death benefit and the transfer-for-value trap
A death benefit paid because of the insured's death is generally free of income tax. Interest added when a beneficiary takes the benefit in installments is taxable.
If a policy is sold or otherwise transferred for value, the buyer's tax-free amount is limited to what the buyer paid for it plus later premiums; the rest of the death benefit is taxable income. The limit doesn't apply when the new owner's basis carries over from the old owner, as in a gift, or to a transfer to the insured, to the insured's partner, to a partnership in which the insured is a partner, or to a corporation in which the insured is a shareholder or officer. Neither exception helps if the transfer is a reportable policy sale, such as a sale to an investor with no family, business or financial tie to the insured. That is why a buy-sell arrangement among co-owners who are not partners can create a tax problem when policies change hands.
Living benefits and their tax
The owner's cost basis, called the investment in the contract, is premiums paid minus amounts already received tax-free, such as dividends taken in cash.
- Surrender: cash value above the basis is ordinary income.
- Withdrawals from a policy that is not a modified endowment contract come from basis first, so they are generally tax-free until basis is used up. One exception: cash paid out in the first 15 years because the death benefit is reduced can be taxed gain first.
- Loans are not taxable while the policy stays in force. If it lapses or is surrendered with a loan outstanding, the cancelled loan counts as an amount received, and any excess over basis is taxed, even though the owner receives no cash.
Worked example: an owner paid $60,000 of premiums and has borrowed against the policy until the loan and interest reach $95,000. If the policy lapses, the $95,000 used to repay the loan is treated as received, and $95,000 - $60,000 = $35,000 is ordinary income with no cash to pay the tax.
Modified endowment contracts and exchanges
A policy funded faster than a seven-pay test allows (at any point in the first seven years, cumulative premiums exceed what would have been paid by then on a policy paid up after seven level annual premiums) becomes a modified endowment contract (MEC). It keeps the tax-free death benefit, but withdrawals and loans come out of gain first and are taxable, with a 10% additional tax before age 59½ unless an exception applies.
Under Section 1035, a life policy can be exchanged tax-free for another life policy, an annuity or a qualified long-term care contract. An annuity can't be exchanged tax-free for a life policy.
On the exam
- Term buys the most cover for a temporary need.
- Dividends received in cash lower the basis used to compute a surrender gain.
- A lapse with a loan can create taxable income without cash.
- A sale of a policy to an unrelated buyer limits the tax-free death benefit.
- MEC loans are taxed gain first, plus 10% before 59½.