A client asking whether a share is cheap needs two numbers: the return she should require for its risk, and the value that return implies. This lesson builds the required return from beta, values a share with the constant-growth dividend model, and reads price-earnings ratios with care.
Required return from beta
The capital asset pricing model (CAPM) sets the return a client should require from a share for the market risk it carries:
k = Rf + beta x (Rm - Rf)
Rf is the risk-free rate, Rm the expected market return and (Rm - Rf) the market risk premium. A share with a beta of 0.9, when Rf is 4% and Rm is 10%, needs k = 4 + 0.9 x 6 = 9.4%. Only market risk raises the required return; firm-specific risk can be diversified away and isn't rewarded. Every input is an estimate: Rf is usually a Treasury yield, beta comes from past returns, and the market premium is a forecast, so the required return is approximate too.
The constant-growth dividend model
A share is worth the present value of the dividends it will pay. If dividends grow at a constant rate g forever and g is below k:
V = D1 / (k - g), where D1 = D0 x (1 + g)
D0 is the dividend just paid and D1 the next one. Worked example: the share above has just paid $1.20 and its dividend should grow 5% a year. D1 = 1.20 x 1.05 = $1.26, so V = 1.26 / (0.094 - 0.05) = $28.64. If it trades at $25, it looks undervalued for a client who accepts those inputs; at $32, overvalued.
Rearranged, k = D1 / P + g: a share's expected return is its dividend yield plus its growth rate, which lets a planner tell a client what a fairly priced share should earn.
How fragile the answer is
The result depends heavily on k - g, a small number. Raising g or lowering k by one point can change the value by a quarter or more (about 30% in the example above), so a planner shows clients a range rather than a single figure. The model fails outright when g is at or above k, and it can't value a company that pays no dividend or whose growth will change sharply; for those, a multistage model, free cash flow or a comparison with similar companies fits better.
Price-earnings ratios
The price-earnings (P/E) ratio compares the price with earnings per share: trailing P/E uses the last 12 months, forward P/E uses next year's estimate. Dividing the dividend model by next year's earnings gives a justified forward P/E:
P / E1 = payout ratio / (k - g)
With a 45% payout, k of 9.4% and g of 5%, the justified forward P/E is 0.45 / 0.044 = 10.23. A higher P/E is justified by faster growth or a lower required return, and a low P/E may signal weak prospects or high risk rather than a bargain. Compare a share's P/E with peers in the same industry and with its own history, and check that the earnings aren't inflated by one-time items.
| Approach | Best suited to | Main weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Constant-growth dividend model | Mature, steady dividend payers | Very sensitive to k - g |
| P/E against peers | Firms with stable, positive earnings | Assumes peers are fairly priced |
| Free cash flow or multistage models | Non-payers and fast growers | Needs many forecasts |
On the exam
- Use D1, not D0, in the numerator.
- Use the market risk premium, not the market return, in the CAPM.
- The model needs g below k.
- Expected return = dividend yield + growth.