Contracts change after they are signed, and winning and fulfilling them costs money. This lesson covers the three ways ASC 606 accounts for a contract modification, then when the costs of obtaining and fulfilling a contract become an asset, and how that asset is amortized and impaired.
When a change is a modification
A contract modification is a change in scope, price or both that the parties approve, in writing, orally or through customary practice. Until it is approved, the original contract is still accounted for. A modification can exist while the parties still dispute the price, or before they have priced an approved change in scope (an unpriced change order). The entity then estimates the price change as variable consideration, subject to the constraint.
Three treatments
- Separate contract. Both must hold: the scope grows by distinct goods or services, and the price rises by their standalone selling prices (adjusted for the circumstances, such as savings on selling costs for an existing customer). The original contract is left alone.
- Prospective. If it isn't a separate contract and the goods or services still to be delivered are distinct from those already delivered, the original contract is treated as terminated and a new one created. The price allocated to the remaining obligations is the consideration not yet recognized as revenue (including amounts already received) plus the consideration added by the modification. Revenue already recognized is untouched.
- Cumulative catch-up. If what remains isn't distinct, because it is part of a single obligation already partly satisfied, the new price and new measure of progress are applied as if they had always been in place, and the difference is adjusted in revenue at the modification date, up or down.
When the remaining items mix both kinds, each is handled in the way that fits the objective of these rules.
Example: a shipyard refits a ferry for 4,000,000, one obligation measured by cost-to-cost with expected costs of 3,000,000. Year 1 costs are 1,200,000 (40%), so Year 1 revenue is 1,600,000. Early in Year 2, before more work, the owner approves adding a passenger lounge built into the refit: the price rises by 600,000 and expected costs by 1,000,000.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| New price | 4,600,000 |
| Progress: 1,200,000 / 4,000,000 | 30% |
| Cumulative revenue: 30% x 4,600,000 | 1,380,000 |
| Catch-up at the modification date | (220,000) |
Revenue falls by 220,000 even though the contract stays profitable.
Costs of obtaining a contract
Incremental costs of obtaining a contract, those the entity would not have incurred without it (a sales commission is the standard case), are recognized as an asset if the entity expects to recover them. Costs it would have incurred win or lose, such as preparing a bid, are expensed unless the customer must pay them regardless. A retainer paid to a sales agent whether or not anything is signed isn't incremental either. As a practical expedient, an entity may expense incremental costs whose asset would be amortized over one year or less.
Costs of fulfilling a contract
Costs covered by another Topic follow it: inventory, property and equipment, internal-use software. Other fulfillment costs become an asset only if all three hold: they relate directly to an existing or specifically identified anticipated contract (direct labor and materials, allocated supervision, subcontractor fees, costs chargeable to the customer); they create or enhance resources that will be used to satisfy future obligations; and they are expected to be recovered. Always expensed: general and administrative costs not chargeable to the customer, wasted resources not reflected in the price, costs of work already performed, and costs that can't be tied to future rather than past performance.
Amortization and impairment
The asset is amortized on a systematic basis that matches the transfer of the goods or services it relates to, including specifically anticipated renewals. A software company that pays a 54,000 commission on a three-year subscription, pays nothing on renewal and expects one renewal year amortizes it over four years, 13,500 a year. A significant change in expected timing is a change in estimate.
At each reporting date, the order is: first the contract's assets under other Topics, such as inventory; then the contract cost asset; then the asset group and reporting unit tests of ASC 360 and 350, with the contract cost asset's carrying amount after its own test included. The contract cost impairment is recognized to the extent the carrying amount exceeds the consideration still expected for the related goods or services, including renewals and amounts received but not yet recognized, unconstrained but adjusted for credit risk, less the direct costs of providing them not yet expensed. A recognized impairment is never reversed.
On the exam
Traps: a discounted add-on treated as a separate contract, revenue already recognized being restated under the prospective method, a bid cost or standing retainer capitalized, and an impairment test that ignores the remaining costs.