Whether a client spends savings down to zero or leaves money behind changes how much capital retirement needs. This lesson compares the three funding approaches planners use and the two risks, a long life and bad early returns, that can undo any of them.
Three ways to size a retirement fund
Every approach starts from the same withdrawal stream: yearly amounts that rise with inflation for the planned number of years. They differ in what is left at the end.
- Capital utilization (spending down): the fund runs to zero after the last planned withdrawal. It needs the least capital.
- Capital preservation: the fund still holds a set dollar amount at the end, usually the amount the client starts with or a bequest goal.
- Purchasing power preservation: the fund still holds an amount with the same buying power as a set sum on the retirement date. It needs the most capital.
Spending the fund down
Capital utilization is the calculation from a basic needs analysis. With the first withdrawal on the retirement date:
C = present value of an annuity due of the first-year withdrawal, at the inflation-adjusted rate, over the years of withdrawals
where the inflation-adjusted rate is (1 + r) / (1 + i) - 1 for nominal return r and inflation i. The client consumes both earnings and principal, and the last withdrawal empties the account.
Leaving a set amount behind
To end with a nominal sum T after n years, add the present value of T at the nominal return:
Capital preservation fund = C + T / (1 + r)^n
The extra amount sits invested for the whole period, so a small deposit today grows to T. When the client wants to finish with the same balance the spending-down method requires, T equals C.
Keeping the leftover's buying power
A dollar amount left after 30 years buys much less than it does on the retirement date. To leave an amount with the buying power of T in retirement-date dollars, the nominal target is T x (1 + i)^n. Discounting it at r gives:
Purchasing power fund = C + T / (1 + inflation-adjusted rate)^n
Example: first-year withdrawal $60,000 at the start of each year for 30 years, 6.5% return, 3% inflation, so the inflation-adjusted rate is 3.3981%. With T = $500,000:
| Approach | Extra capital | Total capital |
|---|---|---|
| Capital utilization | $0 | $1,155,735 |
| Capital preservation | 500,000 / 1.065^30 = $75,593 | $1,231,328 |
| Purchasing power preservation | 500,000 / 1.033981^30 = $183,484 | $1,339,219 |
Longevity and the order of returns
A plan sized to a fixed number of years fails if the client lives longer. For a couple the relevant horizon is how long either spouse may live, which runs well past each one's own life expectancy. Many planners plan to an age the client has only a small chance of reaching, and the preservation approaches leave a reserve if that age is passed.
Average returns also hide sequence-of-returns risk. Two retirees with the same average return can end very differently. If losses come early, while withdrawals are being taken, the retiree sells more units at low prices and the remaining fund has less to recover with. During accumulation, with no withdrawals, the order of returns does not change the ending value. Responses include a cash reserve for the first years, flexible spending rules and income annuities.
On the exam
- Capital preservation discounts the target at the nominal return; purchasing power preservation discounts it at the inflation-adjusted rate. Mixing them up gives the other method's answer.
- The extra amount is discounted over the full horizon, not added at face value.
- Spending down needs the least capital and purchasing power preservation the most, for the same withdrawals.
- Sequence risk matters when withdrawals are being taken; with no cash flows the order of returns does not change the result.
- For a couple, plan to the later of two deaths, not either spouse's average.