For many owners the business is their largest asset and their retirement fund. This lesson covers buy-sell agreements and how to fund them, life insurance traps, sales to family members, sales to an employee stock ownership plan, and how a price is set.
Buy-sell agreements
A buy-sell agreement commits the owners, the business or both to buy an owner's interest when a set event occurs: death, disability, retirement or leaving. It gives the departing owner or the estate a buyer and a price, and keeps control with the remaining owners.
| Feature | Cross-purchase | Entity redemption |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer | the other owners | the business |
| Life policies needed for n owners | n x (n - 1) | n |
| Survivors' basis in the purchased interest | rises by the price paid | unchanged for corporate stock |
| Policies exposed to the business's creditors | no | yes |
A wait-and-see agreement leaves the choice of buyer until the event happens, usually giving the business the first option, the owners the second and the business the remainder. With many owners, a trust or partnership can hold one policy per owner to avoid the cross-purchase policy count.
Insuring the buyout and the key person
Death proceeds are normally free of income tax, but a policy sold or transferred for value loses that treatment, except for the excess of proceeds over what the buyer paid and later premiums. The exceptions are transfers in which the new owner's basis carries over from the old owner (such as most gifts), and transfers to the insured, to a partner of the insured, to a partnership in which the insured is a partner, and to a corporation in which the insured is a shareholder or officer. A transfer of a policy between co-shareholders of a corporation is not on the list, a common trap when a redemption plan is switched to a cross-purchase.
For a policy a business owns on an employee or owner, the employee must be told in writing and must consent before the policy is issued, and the insured must fit an excepted group (such as an employee within the 12 months before death, a director or a highly paid person, or proceeds paid to the insured's heirs), or proceeds above premiums paid become taxable. Key person insurance pays the business for the loss of an essential person's skills, and disability buyout insurance funds a purchase if an owner can no longer work.
Selling within the family
Parents often sell to a child with an installment note, which spreads the gain over the payments, or a self-canceling installment note, which ends at the seller's death in exchange for a higher price or interest rate. A redemption by a family corporation is a problem: shares owned by a spouse, children, grandchildren and parents count as the seller's own, so a partial redemption may be taxed as a dividend. A complete redemption can still be a sale if the seller waives family attribution, keeps no interest other than as a creditor (not even as an employee), acquires none for 10 years, and files an agreement to tell the IRS of any later acquisition.
When stock is more than 35% of the adjusted gross estate (the gross estate less deductible expenses, debts and losses), a Section 303 redemption treats the corporation's purchase of the estate's shares as a sale, up to the death taxes plus funeral and administration expenses.
Selling to employees through an ESOP
An owner of a closely held C corporation who sells shares to an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) can defer the gain under Section 1042 if the owner held the shares at least three years, the ESOP owns at least 30% of the company after the sale, and the owner buys stock or bonds of domestic operating companies within the period from three months before to 12 months after the sale. The replacement securities take a lower basis. For sales after 2027, owners of S corporations may defer gain on up to 10% of the amount realized.
Putting a price on the business
Agreements fix a price by a stated amount, a formula or an appraisal at the event. Common methods are asset-based value (useful for holding companies), multiples of earnings from comparable sales, and capitalized or discounted earnings after adjusting the owner's pay to a market level. A minority interest or one with no ready market is often worth less per share than a controlling interest. A stated price should be updated regularly, because an old price can be unfair to one side.
On the exam
- Cross-purchase: n x (n - 1) policies and a basis increase for survivors.
- A policy moved between co-shareholders is a transfer for value.
- Family attribution can turn a redemption into a dividend.
- Section 1042: C corporation, 3 years, 30%, replacement 3 months before to 12 months after.
- Section 303 covers only death taxes and funeral and administration expenses.