Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Real Estate, Commodities and Collectibles as Holdings

Property, commodities and collectibles can diversify a stock and bond portfolio, but each brings its own costs, liquidity and tax rules. This lesson compares owning property directly with owning REITs, shows how commodity futures are taxed, and explains the collectibles rate and the IRA ban.

9 cards
Study this deck

Real Estate, Commodities and Collectibles as Holdings

In this lesson · 5 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

Property, commodities and collectibles can diversify a stock and bond portfolio, but each brings its own costs, liquidity and tax rules. This lesson compares owning property directly with owning REITs, shows how commodity futures are taxed, and explains the collectibles rate and the IRA ban.

Owning property directly

A rental building gives a client income, possible appreciation and control, at the price of concentration, management work, leverage risk and slow, costly sales. Depreciation shelters part of the rent: residential rental buildings are recovered over 27.5 years and nonresidential buildings over 39 years (IRC 168(c)); land isn't depreciated. A residential building that cost $330,000, excluding land, yields $12,000 of depreciation for a full year ($330,000 / 27.5). Rental losses fall under the passive activity rules, covered with the other loss limits in the tax domain. For exchanges after 2017, a like-kind exchange can defer gain only when real property is exchanged for real property (IRC 1031(a)(1)).

REITs, listed and non-traded

A real estate investment trust (REIT) owns or finances income-producing property and avoids corporate tax on what it pays out, provided it distributes at least 90% of its taxable income, figured before the dividends-paid deduction and excluding net capital gain (IRC 857(a)). Listed REITs trade daily. Non-traded REITs are registered with the SEC but don't trade on an exchange, so they are hard to sell and value, may fund distributions from borrowing or new investors' money, and often pay an external manager fees tied to asset growth.

A REIT distribution can contain three parts:

  • Ordinary REIT dividends, taxed at ordinary rates, not the qualified dividend rates. A client may deduct 20% of these qualified REIT dividends under IRC 199A, a deduction Public Law 119-21 made permanent, so the effective top federal rate is 0.8 x 37% = 29.6%.
  • Capital gain dividends, taxed as long-term gain.
  • Return of capital, untaxed when received, which lowers the client's basis (any excess over basis is taxed as gain).

Worked example: for 2026 a client in the 32% bracket and the 15% capital gain bracket receives $5,000 from a listed REIT: $3,500 ordinary, $1,000 capital gain dividends and $500 return of capital.

PartFederal tax
Ordinary, after the 20% deduction$3,500 x 0.8 x 32% = $896
Capital gain dividends$1,000 x 15% = $150
Return of capital$0 now; basis falls by $500
Total$1,046

Commodity exposure

Clients reach commodities through futures, funds that hold futures, producers' shares or the physical metal. Regulated futures contracts are section 1256 contracts. Each gain or loss is split 60/40 between long-term and short-term, whatever the holding period, and positions still open at year end are marked to their market value and taxed as if closed (IRC 1256(a)). A fund that rolls futures earns the futures' return, which can differ widely from the spot price. Commodities produce no income, so their return comes only from price changes and, in futures, from interest on the collateral.

Collectibles

Art, rugs, antiques, metals, gems, stamps, coins and alcoholic beverages are collectibles. Long-term gain on them is taxed at ordinary rates but never above 28% (IRC 1(h)), so a client in a low bracket pays her ordinary rate, while one in the 32% bracket or higher pays 28%. For this rate, gold and silver bullion count as collectibles. Collectibles pay no income, cost money to store and insure, and trade with wide dealer spreads.

An IRA or self-directed plan account that buys a collectible is treated as distributing the amount paid (IRC 408(m)). Certain U.S. gold, silver and platinum coins and coins issued by a state are excepted, and so is bullion of the purity required for futures delivery if the IRA trustee holds it.

On the exam

  • Ordinary REIT dividends aren't qualified dividends; the 20% deduction lowers their tax.
  • REIT return of capital reduces basis; it isn't income when received.
  • Regulated futures: 60/40 split and year-end marking, regardless of holding period.
  • The 28% collectibles rate is a ceiling, not a flat rate.
  • A collectible bought in an IRA is a distribution of its cost.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Collectibles gain rate
Save
Ordinary REIT dividends and the 20% deduction
Save
REIT payout requirement
Save
Regulated futures 60/40 rule
Save
Collectible bought by an IRA
Save