Clients watch markets swing between long rises and sharp falls and want to know whether anyone can predict the turns. This lesson defines bull and bear markets, shows what falls and recoveries do to a portfolio, and explains what market efficiency implies for a client's strategy.
Bulls, bears and recoveries
Under the rule of thumb the SEC's investor education site uses, a bear market is a slide of at least 20% from a high that lasts two months or longer, and a bull market is a climb of at least 20% from a low over a similar stretch. Measure each move from its starting level: a fall from the previous high, a rise from the low.
Losses and gains aren't symmetric. Worked example: a portfolio that falls 25% needs a 1 / 0.75 - 1 = 33.33% gain just to get back to where it started. A client who sells after the fall and waits for "clear signs" often misses the early, steep part of the rise.
How a downturn tests a plan
Expansions and recessions in the economy tend to show up in stock prices ahead of time, because prices reflect expected earnings. During a long bull market, clients often feel more tolerant of risk than they are, and their stock holdings drift above target. During a bear market, the same clients want out. A planner's tools are set in advance: an allocation that fits the client's capacity and tolerance, a cash or bond reserve for near-term spending so stocks aren't sold at the bottom, and a rebalancing rule that buys what has fallen.
Three degrees of efficiency
A market is informationally efficient when prices already reflect a given set of information, so it can't be used to earn more than the risk justifies after costs:
- Weak form: past prices and trading volumes are already in the price, so chart patterns and trend rules don't earn abnormal returns.
- Semi-strong form: all public information, including financial statements and news, is already in the price, so ordinary research on public data doesn't either.
- Strong form: even private information is in the price. Insider-trading profits show markets aren't strong-form efficient, and trading on such information is illegal.
Each form includes the ones before it.
| Form | Information already in prices | Approach that can't earn excess returns |
|---|---|---|
| Weak | Past prices and volume | Technical analysis |
| Semi-strong | All public information | Technical analysis and analysis of public data |
| Strong | Public and private information | Every approach, including insider knowledge |
Anomalies and their limits
Researchers have found patterns that seemed to beat the market: momentum (recent winners keep winning for a while), value and small-company premiums, and slow price reactions to earnings news. Every test of efficiency also tests a model of what return the risk deserves (the joint-hypothesis problem), so an apparent excess return may be a reward for risk the model missed. Many patterns shrink after they are published, and some vanish once trading costs and taxes are counted.
What it means for a client's strategy
If prices are close to efficient, low-cost, broadly diversified index funds are hard to beat after fees and taxes, and the planner's value lies in allocation, taxes, costs and behavior. A client can still use active managers, but should expect most to trail their benchmarks after costs, and should judge them on risk-adjusted results over long periods rather than one good year.
On the exam
- Measure a bear market's fall from the peak and a bull market's rise from the trough.
- A loss of x needs a gain of x / (1 - x) to recover.
- Weak form rules out price patterns; semi-strong adds public data; strong adds private data.
- Excess returns before costs aren't by themselves evidence against efficiency.