When a client has spare cash and several debts, the order of repayment matters. This lesson ranks debts by after-tax cost, weighs consolidation and federal student loan protections, and outlines what bankruptcy can and cannot do.
Rank by after-tax cost
Paying off a debt earns a sure return equal to the rate it charges. When the interest is deductible, the true cost is lower:
After-tax rate = stated rate x (1 - marginal tax rate)
That formula applies only if the deduction actually reduces the client's tax. For 2026:
- Credit cards and personal loans: interest is personal interest and not deductible.
- Mortgage interest on up to $750,000 of acquisition debt is deductible only if the client itemizes. A client who takes the standard deduction gets no benefit, so the after-tax rate equals the stated rate.
- Student loan interest: up to $2,500 a year is deductible whether or not the client itemizes, phasing out over modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) of $85,000 to $100,000 for single filers and $175,000 to $205,000 for joint filers in 2026.
- Car loan interest: for 2025 through 2028, up to $10,000 a year is deductible, itemizing or not, on a loan taken out after 2024 to buy a new vehicle for personal use, among other conditions: the loan is secured by a first lien on the vehicle, and the vehicle is a car, minivan, van, sport utility vehicle, pickup or motorcycle rated under 14,000 pounds whose final assembly was in the United States. The deduction (after the $10,000 cap) is cut by $200 for each $1,000, or part of $1,000, of MAGI above $100,000 ($200,000 joint). Used cars and leases don't qualify.
Worked example. A client in the 24% bracket who takes the standard deduction has a 21.9% card, a 7.4% loan on a used car, a 6.25% mortgage and a 6.8% student loan whose interest is fully deductible. After-tax rates: 21.9%, 7.4%, 6.25% and 6.8% x 0.76 = 5.168%. Pay extra on the card first, then the car loan, the mortgage and the student loan last.
Avalanche, snowball and consolidation
Paying the highest-rate debt first (the avalanche) costs least. Paying the smallest balance first (the snowball) costs more but gives quick wins that keep some clients going; a plan the client follows beats a cheaper one abandoned.
Consolidation replaces several debts with one. A balance transfer card may charge 0% for a promotional period, but usually adds a fee and a higher rate afterward. A personal loan fixes the rate and the payoff date. A home equity loan offers a lower rate but turns unsecured card debt into debt secured by the house, and for 2026 its interest is not deductible unless the money buys, builds or substantially improves that home. None of these helps if spending keeps exceeding income, which is why the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau suggests looking at the cause of the debt and talking to a nonprofit credit counselor first.
Student loans need extra care
Federal student loans carry protections private loans usually lack: income-driven repayment, forgiveness for some public service work, and discharge at death or total and permanent disability. Refinancing federal loans into a private loan at a lower rate gives these up for good. Weigh the rate saving against how likely the client is to need them.
When debts can't be paid
| Chapter 7 | Chapter 13 | |
|---|---|---|
| Method | Trustee sells nonexempt assets and pays creditors | Debtor repays from income under a court-approved plan |
| Length | Usually a few months | Usually three to five years |
| Who | Subject to a means test if income is above the state median | Individuals with regular income, within debt limits |
| Property | Nonexempt property may be sold | Debtor generally keeps property, including a home in arrears |
Some debts usually survive either chapter: certain taxes, child support and alimony, and student loans unless repaying them would impose an "undue hardship", a test the debtor must prove in court. A secured lender keeps its lien, so a client who wants to keep a financed car must keep paying for it.
On the exam
- Deductible interest lowers the cost only if the deduction is used: no itemizing, no mortgage benefit.
- The car loan deduction covers only new, U.S.-assembled vehicles bought with a loan; the phase-out counts each part of $1,000.
- Consolidating with home equity puts the house at risk, and the interest isn't deductible when the money pays off cards.
- Refinancing federal student loans privately ends their federal protections.
- Student loans are rarely discharged in bankruptcy.