A planner may advise on investments, sell securities, sell insurance and counsel on workplace plans, and each activity has its own regulator. This lesson maps who registers where, what brokers owe retail customers, how insurance is supervised, and when plan advice brings ERISA duties.
Who counts as an investment adviser
Under the Investment Advisers Act, an investment adviser is anyone who, for pay, is in the business of advising others about securities, directly or through writings, or who regularly issues securities analyses or reports for pay. Several groups are carved out, among them:
- banks (with limits);
- lawyers, accountants, engineers and teachers whose advice is only incidental to their profession;
- brokers and dealers whose advice is only incidental to brokerage and who receive no special pay for it;
- publishers of bona fide newspapers and financial publications of general circulation.
An accountant who answers a client's question about selling a fund while preparing her return is inside the carve-out. The same accountant who launches a separate portfolio review service for a fee is not.
SEC or state registration
Which regulator an adviser registers with depends mainly on its regulatory assets under management, the securities portfolios it continuously supervises or manages.
| Adviser's assets under management | Where it registers |
|---|---|
| Under $100 million | With its home state's securities regulator, generally (the statute's $25 million to $100 million mid-sized band is state-registered) |
| $100 million to under $110 million | May choose the SEC, but need not |
| $110 million or more | With the SEC |
| Already with the SEC, later below $110 million | May stay until assets fall below $90 million |
Exceptions let some smaller advisers register with the SEC anyway, including advisers to registered investment companies and a mid-sized adviser that would otherwise have to register in 15 or more states. An SEC-registered firm's individual advisers, called investment adviser representatives, may still have to be licensed by the states where they have a place of business, and states keep the power to bring fraud cases against any adviser.
Brokers and Regulation Best Interest
Broker-dealers generally register with the SEC and join FINRA, the self-regulatory organization that writes and enforces rules for its members and licenses their representatives. When a broker recommends a securities transaction, an investment strategy or a type of account to a retail customer, Regulation Best Interest requires it to act in that customer's best interest at the time of the recommendation, without putting its own interests first. The rule has four parts:
- Care: understand the product's risks, rewards and costs, and have a reasonable basis to believe the recommendation is in this customer's best interest given their investment profile, and that a series of trades isn't excessive taken together.
- Disclosure: in writing, before or at the recommendation, the capacity in which the firm acts, material fees and costs, the scope of services, and material conflicts.
- Conflicts: written policies to identify and disclose or remove conflicts, reduce incentives for representatives, identify and disclose material limits on what may be recommended, and eliminate sales contests, quotas and bonuses tied to selling specific securities within a limited period.
- Compliance: written policies reasonably designed to achieve compliance with the rule as a whole.
Both broker-dealers and SEC-registered advisers give retail investors Form CRS, a short relationship summary. An adviser delivers it before or when the advisory contract is signed, again when it recommends a rollover or a new account or service, posts it on its website, and tells existing clients about changes within 60 days.
Insurance and workplace plans
Under the McCarran-Ferguson Act, the business of insurance is regulated by the states. State insurance departments license agents, approve policy forms and police sales, and federal law does not displace state insurance law unless it specifically relates to insurance. A variable annuity is both an insurance contract and a security: state insurance regulators and the SEC both oversee it, and FINRA Rule 2330 adds suitability and supervision duties when member firms recommend deferred variable annuities.
For employer retirement plans, ERISA, enforced by the Department of Labor, makes a person a plan fiduciary to the extent the person has discretion in managing the plan, exercises any authority or control over its assets, gives investment advice about plan assets for a fee or other compensation, or has discretion in running the plan. The Department of Labor's regulation counts advice as investment advice when it is given regularly under a mutual understanding, is individualized to the plan, and serves as a primary basis for the plan's investment decisions.
On the exam
- Assets under management, not the number of clients, mainly decides SEC versus state registration.
- $100 million to $110 million is the optional zone; $90 million is the floor for staying with the SEC.
- Lawyers and accountants are excluded only while advice is incidental.
- Regulation Best Interest covers recommendations to retail customers.
- Variable annuities answer to both state insurance and securities regulators.