Finance Brain
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Changes in Accounting Principle and Estimate

ASC 250 recognizes three kinds of accounting change: a change in accounting principle, a change in accounting estimate and a change in the reporting entity. This lesson covers how each is reported, retrospectively or prospectively, and what happens when looking back is impracticable.

11 cards
Study this deck

Changes in Accounting Principle and Estimate

In this lesson · 6 sections
Show one section at a time

Terms you'll meet

Tap a card to see what it means.

ASC 250 recognizes three kinds of accounting change: a change in accounting principle, a change in accounting estimate and a change in the reporting entity. This lesson covers how each is reported, retrospectively or prospectively, and what happens when looking back is impracticable.

Three kinds of accounting change

  • Change in accounting principle: moving from one generally accepted method to another, or changing how a method is applied, such as switching inventory cost formulas.
  • Change in accounting estimate: revising an amount because of new information, such as a useful life, a salvage value, expected credit losses or a warranty rate.
  • Change in reporting entity: the statements now describe a different entity, such as consolidated statements replacing the separate statements of the companies in a group, or a change in which subsidiaries are consolidated.

Some things look like changes but aren't. Adopting a method for a transaction that is new, clearly different in substance, or was previously immaterial is not a change in principle. Moving from a method that isn't GAAP to one that is corrects an error. An entity may change principle only when a new pronouncement requires it or when it can justify the new method as preferable; a pronouncement's own transition rules come first.

Retrospective application

A change in principle is applied retrospectively, as if the new method had always been used:

  1. The cumulative effect on all periods before those presented adjusts the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities at the start of the earliest period presented.
  2. The offset goes to opening retained earnings (or another equity component, or net assets for a not-for-profit) of that period.
  3. Each prior period presented is recast for its own effects.

Only direct effects are carried back, including their income tax effects. Indirect effects, such as a loan fee that steps up when reported EBITDA falls, are not recast; any that are actually incurred are recognized in the period of the change.

When retrospective application is impracticable. It counts as impracticable only if it would need significant estimates that can't be objectively separated from hindsight, if it would rest on what management intended back then and that can't be independently verified, or if the entity simply can't do it after every reasonable effort. Then:

  • if the cumulative effect is known but the period-by-period effects aren't, apply the new method from the start of the earliest period it can be applied to, adjusting that period's opening retained earnings;
  • if not even the cumulative effect can be determined, apply the new method prospectively from the earliest date practicable.

Changes in estimate

A change in estimate is prospective: it affects the period of change and, if relevant, later periods. Prior statements are never restated and no pro forma amounts are shown.

Some changes in principle can't be separated from a change in estimate. ASC 250 names a change in depreciation, amortization or depletion method as the example and treats it as a change in estimate effected by a change in principle: prospective, but allowed only if the new method is preferable, and it carries the principle-change disclosures. When a change can't be classified as one or the other, it is treated as an estimate.

Two worked examples

Retrospective. At the start of Year 3, a building-supplies distributor moves from weighted-average cost to FIFO and presents Years 2 and 3. FIFO inventory would have been 40,000 higher at the end of Year 1 and 55,000 higher at the end of Year 2. The tax rate is 25%.

ItemPretaxNet of 25% tax
Opening Year 2 retained earnings40,00030,000
Year 2 net income, as recast15,00011,250
Opening Year 3 retained earnings55,00041,250

Prospective. A press bought for 240,000 at the start of Year 1 was depreciated straight-line over 10 years with no salvage, 24,000 a year. At the start of Year 4, its carrying amount is 168,000. The company now expects 6 more years of use and an 18,000 salvage value. Year 4 depreciation is (168,000 - 18,000) / 6 = 25,000; earlier years are untouched.

Change in reporting entity and disclosures

A change in reporting entity is applied retrospectively to every period presented. A business combination and the consolidation of a variable interest entity are not changes in reporting entity.

Disclosures in the period of change:

  • Principle: the method of applying the change; its effect on income from continuing operations, net income, any other affected line item and per-share amounts for each period presented; the cumulative effect on opening retained earnings of the earliest period; the nature of and reason for the change, including why the new method is preferable; and, if retrospective application was impracticable, why and what was done instead.
  • Estimate: for a change with effects spread over future years, such as a revised useful life, its effect on income from continuing operations, net income and per-share amounts of the current period.
  • Reporting entity: the nature of and reason for the change, and its effect on income from continuing operations, net income, other comprehensive income and per-share amounts for all periods presented.

On the exam

Classify the change first: principle (retrospective), estimate (prospective, including a new depreciation method) or reporting entity (retrospective). Traps: a cumulative effect in current income (a pre-ASC 250 approach), adjusting the current year's opening balance instead of the earliest period's, forgetting tax, and restating for a revised useful life.

Independent exam-prep material. Not affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, CFA Institute or CFP Board. Not financial advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Retrospective application (ASC 250)
Save
Retrospective application is impracticable
Save
Change in accounting estimate
Save
Change in depreciation method
Save
Change in reporting entity
Save