A parent that controls another company reports the two as one economic entity. This lesson covers when a subsidiary must be consolidated, how the investment account is replaced by the subsidiary's assets and liabilities, and how the group's income is built in the years after acquisition.
When a parent consolidates
A parent consolidates every entity in which it holds a controlling financial interest. Under the voting interest model, the usual sign of control is owning, directly or through other subsidiaries, more than 50% of the voting shares. Control can also exist with less than a majority, for example through an agreement with other shareholders, or arise under the variable interest entity model, which this lesson doesn't cover. Limited partnerships have their own test. For a not-for-profit, ASC 958-810 sets its own control and economic interest tests.
Owning a majority doesn't settle the question when control does not actually rest with the owner. That happens when a court supervises a subsidiary in bankruptcy or legal reorganization, when currency controls or other limits imposed by a foreign government put the parent's control in real doubt, or when minority holders have substantive participating rights, the power to block the ordinary decisions that run the business (for example, a veto over the operating budget and key hires). Two differences don't justify leaving a subsidiary out:
- Different operations. A restaurant chain must consolidate the hotel it owns, however unlike the rest of the group it is.
- Different year ends. The subsidiary can usually prepare statements for the parent's period. If the gap is no more than about three months, its own statements are usually acceptable, with disclosure of material events in between.
Replacing the investment account
The parent's books carry one asset, the investment in the subsidiary. Consolidation removes it and puts the subsidiary's individual assets and liabilities in its place, on a worksheet; neither company's ledger changes.
At the acquisition date the acquisition method measures the subsidiary's identifiable assets and liabilities at fair value, including intangibles it never recorded. Goodwill is the price paid above the fair value of those net assets. Legal, valuation and advisory fees for the deal are expenses of the period, not part of the price.
The basic elimination entry debits the subsidiary's own equity accounts, debits the excess of fair value over carrying amount to the assets concerned, debits goodwill, and credits the investment. Because the subsidiary's equity is eliminated, consolidated equity at the acquisition date is simply the parent's equity. The subsidiary's retained earnings earned before the acquisition never reach consolidated retained earnings.
A worked example
On January 1 a kitchen equipment maker pays 2,400,000 in cash for all the shares of a regional distributor. The distributor's equity is 2,000,000: common stock 300,000, paid-in capital 500,000 and retained earnings 1,200,000. Its warehouse is worth 250,000 more than its carrying amount and has 20 years of life left, and its inventory is worth 60,000 more than cost.
| Elimination entry, January 1 | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Common stock (distributor) | 300,000 | |
| Additional paid-in capital (distributor) | 500,000 | |
| Retained earnings (distributor) | 1,200,000 | |
| Warehouse | 250,000 | |
| Inventory | 60,000 | |
| Goodwill: 2,400,000 - (2,000,000 + 250,000 + 60,000) | 90,000 | |
| Investment in distributor | 2,400,000 |
The fair value adjustments then flow through consolidated income. In Year 1 the warehouse adds 250,000 / 20 = 12,500 of depreciation, and the inventory step-up adds 60,000 to cost of goods sold when those goods are sold, a total of 72,500 if all of them are sold in Year 1. Goodwill is tested for impairment rather than amortized, unless a private company or a not-for-profit elects the alternative that amortizes goodwill, generally over 10 years.
After the acquisition date
Consolidated net income is the parent's income from its own operations, plus the subsidiary's net income, minus the extra depreciation, amortization and cost of sales that come from the acquisition-date fair values, with intercompany items removed. Two traps:
- Investment income. Whatever the parent records from the subsidiary (dividend income under the cost method, or equity in earnings) is eliminated, because the subsidiary's revenues and expenses are already included line by line.
- Acquisitions during the year. The subsidiary's revenues and expenses are included only from the date it was acquired. Its results before that date belong to its former owners.
How the parent carries the investment on its own books doesn't change the consolidated statements; it only changes the elimination entries.
On the exam
Expect to build consolidated balances from two sets of books. Start with the acquisition-date fair values and goodwill, eliminate the investment against the subsidiary's equity, then add the year's extra depreciation and remove intercompany dividends. For a wholly owned subsidiary, consolidated equity at acquisition equals the parent's equity, never the sum of both companies'.