Too little life insurance leaves a family selling the house; too much wastes premium that could fund retirement. This lesson shows the two main ways planners size a death benefit, how to discount an income stream for inflation, and which resources reduce the need.
Two ways to size the benefit
The human life value approach asks what the insured's future earnings are worth to the family. Take the part of each year's earnings that would have supported the family (after the insured's own taxes and personal spending), project it to retirement with expected raises, and discount it to today. It gives a ceiling on sensible cover, but it ignores what the family already owns and what it will actually spend.
The needs approach builds the benefit from the family's own plan:
- Add the cash needs due at death: final expenses, debts to pay off (often the mortgage), an emergency fund and education funding.
- Add the present value of the income needs: what the survivors must draw each year to keep living as planned, for as long as each need lasts.
- Subtract the resources already available: existing life insurance, savings and investments the family would use, and survivor benefits from Social Security or a pension.
The result is the extra insurance to buy. Death benefits are generally free of income tax, so they are counted in full; a retirement account the family would draw on is counted after the tax due on withdrawal.
Discounting income needs for inflation
Survivors' spending usually rises with inflation. If each year's payment grows at inflation rate i and the money earns r, discount level payments at the inflation-adjusted rate:
Inflation-adjusted rate = (1 + r) / (1 + i) - 1
Use that rate for the number of years of need, with payments at the beginning of each year when the family starts drawing at once. Using r - i is only an approximation, and the error grows with the length of the need.
Worked example: a surviving spouse needs $60,000 a year in today's dollars for 15 years, drawn at the start of each year, rising with 3% inflation, and the money earns 6%. The rate is 1.06 / 1.03 - 1 = 2.9126%. The present value of an annuity due of $60,000 for 15 years at that rate is $741,819.
How long the money must last
After the income years are set, the planner chooses between two ways of funding them:
- Capital liquidation spends both earnings and principal, so the fund reaches zero when the need ends. It needs the smaller amount.
- Capital retention keeps the principal intact and lives on the earnings alone, leaving the principal to heirs or as a cushion against a longer life than expected. It needs much more insurance.
A planner often uses liquidation for needs with a clear end, such as income until the youngest child is grown, and retention when a spouse may live for decades or the client wants to leave the capital.
Who needs cover and the usual gaps
- A spouse who stays home with children needs cover too: the family would have to pay for childcare and household help.
- Group life through work often equals one or two years' salary and ends with the job, so it is counted as a resource only with care.
- Social Security survivor benefits for a spouse caring for young children stop when the youngest child reaches 16, unless the child is disabled, and many spouses then receive nothing until much later, a gap the plan must fund.
On the exam
- Needs = cash needs + present value of income needs - existing resources.
- Human life value uses the earnings that support the family, not gross pay.
- Use (1 + r) / (1 + i) - 1, not r - i, and match payment timing to the stem.
- Capital retention needs more insurance than capital liquidation.