An error found in statements already issued is corrected by restating them, not by running the correction through the current year's income. This lesson covers what counts as an error, how a restatement works net of tax, why some errors fix themselves, and what must be disclosed.
What counts as an error
An error is a mistake in recognition, measurement, presentation or disclosure that comes from one of these:
- misapplying GAAP, including using a method that isn't GAAP (moving to GAAP from such a method is a correction, not a change in principle);
- overlooking or misusing facts that existed when the statements were prepared;
- an arithmetic mistake.
The test is whether the information existed and could have been used at the time. A revision prompted by new information, such as a customer's later bankruptcy, is a change in estimate and is handled prospectively. An error correction is not an accounting change.
Restatement and the prior-period adjustment
A material error in previously issued statements is reported as a prior-period adjustment by restating:
- The cumulative effect of the error on periods before those presented corrects the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities at the start of the earliest period presented.
- The offset adjusts opening retained earnings (or net assets, for a not-for-profit) of that period, net of the related income tax effect.
- Each prior period presented is corrected for its own effects.
If only the current year is presented, the whole cumulative effect, net of tax, adjusts the current year's opening retained earnings and appears in the statement of retained earnings (or changes in equity). It never passes through current net income.
Counterbalancing and non-counterbalancing errors
Many errors reverse by themselves. A counterbalancing error overstates income in one year and understates it by the same amount the next. If ending inventory is overstated at the end of Year 1, Year 1 income is too high and Year 2 cost of sales is too high, so once Year 2's books are closed, retained earnings is right again. Found after that, it needs no adjustment to retained earnings, though any comparative years presented are still restated. Found during Year 2, opening retained earnings is reduced, net of tax. Missed accruals and prepayments behave the same way.
A non-counterbalancing error stays in retained earnings until it has fully reversed. Expensing equipment that should have been capitalized understates retained earnings until the equipment would have been fully depreciated.
(Counterbalancing is textbook terminology, not a term ASC 250 uses.)
A worked example
During Year 3, a landscaping company finds that a 60,000 mower bought at the start of Year 1 was expensed. It should have been depreciated straight-line over 5 years with no salvage, 12,000 a year. The company presents Years 2 and 3, will file amended returns, and its tax rate is 25%.
| Item | Pretax | Net of 25% tax |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 expense overstated (60,000 - 12,000) | 48,000 | 36,000: increase to opening Year 2 retained earnings |
| Year 2 depreciation never recorded | 12,000 | 9,000: Year 2 net income restated down |
| Cumulative at the start of Year 3 | 36,000 | 27,000: increase to opening Year 3 retained earnings |
Year 2's books are closed, so the correcting entry in Year 3 is:
Dr Equipment 60,000 / Cr Accumulated depreciation 24,000 / Cr Income taxes payable 9,000 / Cr Retained earnings 27,000.
The mower then carries 36,000 (60,000 - 24,000), and Year 3 takes its normal 12,000 of depreciation.
Disclosures
In the period the statements are restated, the entity discloses:
- that previously issued statements have been restated, and the nature of the error;
- the correction's effect on each affected line item and per-share amount for each prior period presented;
- the cumulative effect on retained earnings (or other equity) at the start of the earliest period presented;
- the effect on each prior period's net income, both before and after income tax (with single-year statements, the effect on opening retained earnings and on last year's net income).
Statements of later periods need not repeat these disclosures.
On the exam
Expect to compute a restated income figure, a retained earnings adjustment net of tax, or the correcting entry. Traps: running the correction through current income; adjusting retained earnings for a counterbalancing error that has already reversed; forgetting tax; and treating new information as an error.