A lessee's lease liability is the present value of its lease payments, so what counts as a lease payment decides the numbers. This lesson covers residual value guarantees, purchase options, termination penalties and variable payments, and the events that make a lessee remeasure the liability later.
What goes into lease payments
At commencement, a lessee's lease payments for the lease term are:
- fixed payments, including in-substance fixed payments (variable in form but unavoidable, such as a guaranteed minimum), less lease incentives receivable;
- the exercise price of a purchase option the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise;
- amounts probable of being owed under a residual value guarantee (in practice, the expected shortfall);
- variable payments linked to an index or a rate, such as a benchmark interest rate or the Consumer Price Index, measured at the commencement-date index or rate;
- a termination penalty, if the lease term assumes the lessee will terminate;
- fees paid to the owners of a special-purpose entity for structuring the deal.
Left out: variable payments tied to the lessee's use or performance (a percentage of sales, a charge per hour or per mile), any guarantee of the lessor's debt, and amounts allocated to nonlease components such as maintenance services.
Residual value guarantees
In a residual value guarantee (RVG), the lessee promises the lessor that the asset will be worth at least a set amount when the lease ends and pays any shortfall. For measuring the liability, only the shortfall the lessee expects to pay goes in: if it guarantees 70,000 and expects the asset to be worth 62,000, the lease payment is 8,000. (The classification test uses the guarantee differently; see the classification lesson.)
Three related points:
- A charge for damage, excess wear or excess usage is not an RVG. It can't be measured at commencement and is treated like a variable payment.
- A lessor's right to make the lessee buy the asset at a stated price works like a guaranteed residual: the full price is a lease payment.
- An RVG the lessee buys from an unrelated insurer for the lessor's benefit doesn't reduce the lease payments unless the lessor releases the lessee, and the premium is not a lease payment.
Purchase options and variable payments
A purchase option price is included only when the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise it, judged from economic incentives such as a price well below the expected fair value. If it is included, the lease is a finance lease and the right-of-use (ROU) asset is amortized over the asset's useful life.
Index-based payments are measured once, at the commencement-date index. When the index later rises, the liability is not updated: the extra cash is variable lease cost in the period it is incurred. The current index is picked up only when the liability is remeasured for another reason; a change in the index or rate is not itself the resolution of a contingency (ASU 2018-10).
Usage- or performance-based payments are left out of the liability unless a resolved contingency makes them fixed. They are expensed as incurred; if a payment is triggered by reaching a target, its cost is recognized as soon as reaching the target is probable, and reversed once it becomes probable the target won't be met.
When the liability is remeasured
A lessee remeasures its lease payments when:
- the amount it expects to owe under an RVG changes;
- the lease term changes;
- its judgment about exercising a purchase option changes;
- a contingency is resolved so that variable payments become fixed for the rest of the term;
- the lease is modified and the change isn't accounted for as a separate contract.
The term and purchase options are reassessed only when the lessee exercises an option it wasn't expected to (or passes up one it was), when an event written into the contract forces the decision, or after a significant event or change in circumstances within the lessee's control, such as building costly improvements. A change in market rents alone is not such an event.
The change in the liability adjusts the ROU asset; once the ROU asset reaches zero, any further reduction goes to profit or loss. The discount rate is updated at the remeasurement date, except when the change comes from an RVG, from a resolved variable-payment contingency, or from a term or purchase option the original rate already took into account.
A worked example
On January 1, a vineyard leases a grape harvester for 4 years at 40,000 at each year end. Its incremental borrowing rate is 6%. It guarantees the lessor a residual value of 70,000 and expects the harvester to be worth 62,000, so it expects to pay 8,000.
- Present value of the payments: 40,000 x 3.46511 = 138,604.
- Present value of the expected RVG payment: 8,000 / 1.06^4 = 6,337.
- Lease liability and ROU asset at commencement: 144,941.
At the end of Year 2, after the second payment, the liability is 80,456. The vineyard now expects the harvester to be worth only 50,000, so it expects to owe 20,000 under the guarantee, 12,000 more. The rate stays at 6% because the change comes from an RVG:
- Increase: 12,000 / 1.06^2 = 10,680.
- Entry: Dr ROU asset 10,680 / Cr Lease liability 10,680, giving a liability of 91,136.
On the exam
Traps: including the full guaranteed amount, putting sales-based rent in the liability, remeasuring every time an index moves, including a purchase option that isn't reasonably certain, and updating the discount rate for an RVG change.