A loss contingency is an existing situation whose loss will be confirmed or ruled out by a future event, such as a lawsuit's verdict. This lesson covers when to accrue it, when only to disclose it, how much to accrue, and how litigation and guarantees are handled.
Probable, reasonably possible and remote
ASC 450-20 sorts the chance that the future event confirms a loss into three bands:
- Probable: the event is likely to occur.
- Reasonably possible: more than remote but less than likely.
- Remote: the chance is slight.
An estimate alone doesn't make a contingency: a year-end payroll accrual or the useful life used for amortization is estimated, but the cost itself is certain. General business risks, such as a possible recession, aren't loss contingencies either: no "reserve for general contingencies" may be accrued, and ASC 450 requires no disclosure of them.
Accrue, disclose or do nothing
A loss is accrued (Dr Loss, Cr Liability, or a reduction of an asset) only when both conditions are met:
- Information available before the statements are issued (or available to be issued) shows it is probable that an asset was impaired or a liability incurred at the balance sheet date.
- The amount can be reasonably estimated.
| Likelihood | Amount estimable | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Probable | Yes, as an amount or a range | Accrue, and disclose its nature (sometimes the amount) |
| Probable | No | Disclose only |
| Reasonably possible | Either | Disclose only |
| Remote | Either | Nothing, except guarantees |
A disclosure describes the contingency and gives an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss, or states that no estimate can be made. An unasserted claim, one no claimant has yet raised, is disclosed only if it is probable a claim will be made and an unfavorable outcome is at least reasonably possible.
Measuring the accrual
Accrue the best estimate. When the estimate is a range and no amount in it is more likely than any other, accrue the minimum of the range, not the midpoint, and disclose the further exposure if it is at least reasonably possible.
Example: a maker of space heaters finds a wiring fault in units already sold and concludes a recall is probable. It estimates the cost at 180,000 to 420,000, with no figure more likely. It accrues 180,000 (Dr Recall loss 180,000 / Cr Recall liability 180,000) and discloses a reasonably possible further loss of up to 240,000.
Litigation after year end
What matters is when the cause arose. If the event that caused the loss happened by the balance sheet date, an accrual can be needed even when the suit is filed, or settled, after year end but before the statements are issued. A settlement in that window is evidence of the amount. A loss whose cause arises after year end, such as a January fire at an uninsured plant, is never accrued at December 31; it is disclosed if omitting it would mislead.
Guarantees and warranties
A guarantee has two parts: standing ready to pay (noncontingent) and possibly paying (contingent). At inception the guarantor recognizes a liability for the guarantee's fair value, even when payment is remote; for a standalone, arm's-length guarantee to an unrelated party, the fee received is used. The contingent part follows ASC 450-20, except that for a financial guarantee, such as a guarantee of a loan, the expected credit loss is measured under ASC 326-20 and recognized as well (ASU 2016-13). The guarantor discloses the guarantee's nature, its maximum potential payments and the carrying amount even when payment is remote. Product warranties are excluded from that fair value recognition: a standard warranty's expected cost is accrued when the product is sold.
On the exam
Watch for the range trap (accrue the minimum, not the midpoint), a reasonably possible loss being accrued, a general reserve, and a post-year-end event whose cause arose after the balance sheet date.