ASC 820 defines fair value once for every Topic that uses it. This lesson covers the exit-price definition, which market supplies the price, how transaction and transport costs are treated, highest and best use for nonfinancial assets, and the three valuation approaches.
An exit price
Fair value is the price at which an asset would be sold, or a liability transferred, in an orderly transaction between market participants on the measurement date. Each part matters:
- Exit price: the price to sell, not the price to buy. At initial recognition the two are often equal, but not always, for example in a related-party deal or a forced sale.
- Orderly transaction: one with the usual marketing period, not a distressed or forced sale.
- Market participants: independent, knowledgeable buyers and sellers who are able and willing to transact, acting in their own economic interest. The measurement uses their assumptions, not the reporting entity's own plans.
- The item's characteristics: condition, location and any restriction that would pass to a buyer are reflected. A contractual restriction on selling an equity security is not part of the security, so it is ignored in measuring fair value and disclosed instead (ASU 2022-03). ASU 2026-03 will require investment companies to reflect such restrictions, for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2027.
For a liability, fair value assumes it is transferred to a market participant, not settled, and it includes nonperformance risk, which takes in the entity's own credit risk.
Which market sets the price
- If there is a principal market, the one where the item trades in the greatest volume and with the most activity, use its price, even if another market would pay more on the measurement date.
- With no principal market, use the most advantageous market: the one that would leave the most after both transaction costs and transport costs.
The entity must have access to the market, though it needn't be able to sell that item on that date. The market it normally uses is presumed to be the principal one.
Transaction costs help choose the most advantageous market but are never deducted from fair value: they belong to the transaction, not the asset. Transport costs are deducted when the asset's location affects its price, as it does for a commodity.
Example. A grain cooperative holds 20,000 bushels of soybeans, with no principal market.
| Per bushel | Market X | Market Y | Market Z |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 12.40 | 12.10 | 12.60 |
| Transaction costs | (0.50) | (0.15) | (0.70) |
| Transport costs | (0.30) | (0.20) | (0.25) |
| Net received | 11.60 | 11.75 | 11.65 |
Market Y nets the most, so it is the most advantageous market. Fair value is its price less transport only: 12.10 - 0.20 = 11.90 a bushel, or 238,000. Market Z has the highest price but nets less.
Highest and best use for nonfinancial assets
A nonfinancial asset, such as a building, machine or brand, is measured at its highest and best use by market participants: the use that maximizes its value and that is legally permissible, physically possible and financially feasible. The entity's current use is presumed to be the highest and best use unless market factors suggest otherwise, and it doesn't matter if the entity intends something else, such as not using the asset at all.
That use sets the valuation premise: either in combination with other assets (in use) or on its own. If a brewery's copper kettles would fetch more as scrap copper than as part of a working brew line, their fair value is the scrap value, even while the brewery keeps brewing; it then discloses that the current use differs from the highest and best use. Highest and best use doesn't apply to financial assets or to liabilities.
Three valuation approaches
- Market approach: prices and other information from transactions in identical or comparable items. Examples are multiples drawn from comparable companies and matrix pricing for debt securities.
- Income approach: converts future amounts, such as cash flows or earnings, to one current amount. Examples are the multiperiod excess earnings method for some intangibles, option-pricing models and present value techniques.
- Cost approach: what it would cost now to replace the asset's service capacity, that is, to buy or build a substitute of comparable utility, adjusted for physical, functional and economic obsolescence.
An entity uses the techniques that suit the circumstances and have enough data, maximizing observable inputs. When it uses several, it weighs the results and picks the point in the range that best represents fair value. Techniques are applied consistently; a justified change in technique is a change in accounting estimate, without the usual ASC 250 estimate disclosures.
On the exam
Expect a most-advantageous-market calculation. Traps: deducting transaction costs from fair value, using a better price outside the principal market, using the entity's intended use instead of market participants' highest and best use, and applying highest and best use to a financial asset.