Choosing a deductible
A higher deductible is retention by design: the household self-insures the first part of each loss in exchange for a lower premium. The right deductible is one the household could pay from its emergency fund without strain, where the premium saved is large relative to the extra amount it would pay per claim.
Worked example: raising an auto deductible from $500 to $2,000 saves $280 a year. Each claim would now cost the household $1,500 more. The saving pays for itself unless claims come more often than $280 / $1,500 = 0.1867 a year, about one claim every 5.36 years. A careful driver with a solid emergency fund should take the higher deductible.