Comparing the first year
Worked example. A couple can buy a $420,000 home with $84,000 down and a $336,000 30-year loan at 6.5%, or rent a similar home for $2,450 a month plus $240 a year of renters insurance. They take the standard deduction either way, could earn 4% after tax on the down payment, and expect 3% appreciation.
| Owning, year 1 | Amount |
|---|---|
| Mortgage interest | $21,729 |
| Property tax, insurance, maintenance | $5,200 + $1,900 + $4,200 |
| Lost earnings on $84,000 at 4% | $3,360 |
| Less appreciation, 3% of $420,000 | ($12,600) |
| Economic cost | $23,789 |
Renting costs 2,450 x 12 + 240 = $29,640, so owning is cheaper by these assumptions. Change appreciation to zero and owning costs $36,389. The appreciation and holding-period assumptions usually decide the answer, so planners test several.