Available for sale: a two-question test
An AFS security is impaired when its fair value is below amortized cost. The holder then asks:
- Does it intend to sell, or is it more likely than not that it will have to sell, before amortized cost is recovered? If so, any allowance is written off and amortized cost is written down to fair value, with the whole decline in net income. The reduced amount becomes the new amortized cost.
- If not, is any of the decline a credit loss? The holder compares the present value of the cash flows it expects to collect, discounted at the effective rate at purchase, with amortized cost. Any shortfall is an allowance for credit losses, but the allowance can't exceed the amount by which fair value is below amortized cost (the fair value floor). The rest of the decline goes to OCI.
The assessment is done security by security; a general allowance for a portfolio isn't allowed. The length of time fair value has been below amortized cost can't be used, alone or with other factors, to conclude that no credit loss exists. If expected cash flows later improve, the allowance is reduced through net income, but never below zero. That reversal wasn't possible under the old model.